Supplements to a recent proposal for permissible uncertainty of measurements in laboratory medicine

Abstract

Abstract: The DGKL Working Group Guide Limits (Arbeitsgruppe Richtwerte) has published a proposal for deriving permissible analytical uncertainty limits related to biological variation data. Reference intervals were used to estimate biological variation. Biological variation data as basis for permissible uncertainty limits are generally accepted. These concepts usually apply a fixed factor leading to unrealistic stringent limits for quantities with a relatively small biological variation and to very permissive limits for quantities with relatively large biological variation. The working group has suggested a non-linear relation between biological variation and permissible uncertainty limits. The new approach has been exemplified with 84 quantities listed in the RiliBÄK (official German guidelines). The algorithms published allowed to derive permissible limits for all quantitative measurands in laboratory medicine. After its publication, three supplements appear necessary: 1. additional specifications of standard uncertainty, 2. a discussion on permissible limits for diagnosis and monitoring purposes, and 3. a discussion on circular reasoning in our approach.