Responding to the State of the World’s Nursing 2020 report in Aotearoa New Zealand: Aligning our nursing workforce to universal health coverage and health equity
{"title":"Responding to the State of the World’s Nursing 2020 report in Aotearoa New Zealand: Aligning our nursing workforce to universal health coverage and health equity","authors":"Linda M Chalmers","doi":"10.36951/27034542.2020.007","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The World Health Organization's State of the World's Nursing (SoWN) 2020 report identified that the international maldistribution of the nursing workforce, particularly in high-income and developed countries, greatly impeded the United Nation's Sustainable Development Goals and the World Health Organization priority of universal health coverage Policy advice in the SoWN report emphasises investment in growing the nursing workforce to not only address a calculated shortfall of 5 9 million nurses internationally, but to augment domestic production of nurses in countries who are over-reliant on nurses trained overseas Aotearoa New Zealand is one such country that is heavily reliant on internationally qualified nurses, with 27% of its total nursing workforce being migrants Key prescriptions from the report include investment in nursing workforce data and its management;nursing leadership;nursing education;and the regulation of nurses The report provides timely advice on the deep over-reliance on migrant nurses particularly in the context of the COVID-19 global pandemic, economic recession, and ballooning unemployment Formulating a coherent national nursing workforce strategy is urgently needed to address the nursing workforce in Aotearoa New Zealand This important work must align with improving population health outcomes and reducing the unacceptably high rates of health disparity However, the SoWN report is all but silent on the international Indigenous nursing workforce and Indigenous health To atone for this omission, Aotearoa New Zealand will need to address the persistent inequity of Māori in its nursing workforce by investing in the domestic growth of Māori nurses, as well as in Māori nursing leadership capacity and capability in order to better contribute to reducing Māori health inequity Failure to invest in the domestic production of the nursing workforce at this juncture, and instead continuing to rely on the immigration of internationally qualified nurses would be unethical Such critical responses to the SoWN report will be of value to Aotearoa New Zealand and international nursing audiences Alternate abstract:I puta te kī a te pūrongo State of the World's Nursing (SoWN) 2020 ko te hē o te horapa o te kāhui kaimahi tapuhi puta noa i te ao, otirā i ngā whenua whiwhinga pūtea-nui, whenua kua eke ki ngā taumata whanaketanga, tētahi ārai nui mo te whāinga mātua o ngā Whāinga Whanaketanga Toitū o te Huihuinga o ngā Whenua o te Ao, me te Ropū Hauora o te Ao E kī ana ngā kupu tohutohu kaupapa here o te pūrongo SoWN he mea nui te haumitanga ki te whakatupu i te kāhui kaimahi tapuhi, kāpā kia whakatikaina te korenga tapuhi 5 9 miriona huri noa i te ao, engari hei whakapiki i te whakaputanga tapuhi i te wā kāinga i ngā whenua e whakawhirinaki atu ana ki ngā tapuhi kua whakangungua i tāwāhi He whenua a Aotearoa e whakawhirinaki atu ana ki ngā tapuhi i whai tohu i tāwāhi, arā, 27 orau o te kāhui kaimahi tapuhi he tangata no whenua kē Ko ngā tohutohu matua o te pūrongo ko te haumi ki ngā raraunga kāhui kaimahi tapuhi me ona whakahaere;ngā mahi hautū i te ao tapuhi;te mātauranga tapuhi;me ngā whakaritenga ā-ture mo ngā tapuhi Tā tēnei pūrongo he hora whakamaherehere hāngai mo te kaha rawa o te whakawhirinaki ki ngā tapuhi o tāwāhi i ēnei rā o te mate urutā o KOWHEORI-19, te paheketanga ohaoha, me te kakenga nui o te koremahi Me mātua whakaoti tētahi rautaki tapuhi ā-motu whai take hei whakatikatika i to Aotearoa kaha whakawhirinaki atu ki ngā tapuhi no whenua kē Me whakahāngai tēnei mahi hira ki te whakapikinga o ngā putanga hauora taupori, me te whakaheke i ngā putanga tino rerekē mo tēnā wehenga mo tēnā wehenga o te taupori Ahakoa ēnei mea katoa, kei te ngū tonu te pūrongo SoWN mo te kāhui tapuhi iwi taketake ā-ao, me te hauora iwi taketake Hei whakatikatika i tēnei hapa nui, me tahuri Aotearoa ki te whakapiki i te korenga e orite o te iwi Māori i tona kāhui kaimahi mā te haumi ki te whakapikinga i te kāinga nei o gā tapuhi Māori, tae atu ki ngā āheinga me ngā pūmanawa o ngā kaihautū tapuhi Māori, hei mea e heke ai te korenga e orite o te hauora o te iwi Māori Ki te kore e tika te haumi ki te whakaputanga i te kāinga o te kāhui kaimahi tapuhi i Aotearoa i tēnei wā, ka kīa he takahanga i te tika kia whakawhirinaki kau atu ki ngā kāhui taetae mai o ngā tapuhi whai tohu no ngā whenua o tāwāhi Ka noho ko ngā urupare arotake i te Pūrongo hei mea whai hua mo Aotearoa me ngā kaipānui tapuhi o te ao","PeriodicalId":77298,"journal":{"name":"Nursing praxis in New Zealand inc","volume":"48 1","pages":"7-19"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2020-07-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"5","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Nursing praxis in New Zealand inc","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.36951/27034542.2020.007","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 5
Abstract
The World Health Organization's State of the World's Nursing (SoWN) 2020 report identified that the international maldistribution of the nursing workforce, particularly in high-income and developed countries, greatly impeded the United Nation's Sustainable Development Goals and the World Health Organization priority of universal health coverage Policy advice in the SoWN report emphasises investment in growing the nursing workforce to not only address a calculated shortfall of 5 9 million nurses internationally, but to augment domestic production of nurses in countries who are over-reliant on nurses trained overseas Aotearoa New Zealand is one such country that is heavily reliant on internationally qualified nurses, with 27% of its total nursing workforce being migrants Key prescriptions from the report include investment in nursing workforce data and its management;nursing leadership;nursing education;and the regulation of nurses The report provides timely advice on the deep over-reliance on migrant nurses particularly in the context of the COVID-19 global pandemic, economic recession, and ballooning unemployment Formulating a coherent national nursing workforce strategy is urgently needed to address the nursing workforce in Aotearoa New Zealand This important work must align with improving population health outcomes and reducing the unacceptably high rates of health disparity However, the SoWN report is all but silent on the international Indigenous nursing workforce and Indigenous health To atone for this omission, Aotearoa New Zealand will need to address the persistent inequity of Māori in its nursing workforce by investing in the domestic growth of Māori nurses, as well as in Māori nursing leadership capacity and capability in order to better contribute to reducing Māori health inequity Failure to invest in the domestic production of the nursing workforce at this juncture, and instead continuing to rely on the immigration of internationally qualified nurses would be unethical Such critical responses to the SoWN report will be of value to Aotearoa New Zealand and international nursing audiences Alternate abstract:I puta te kī a te pūrongo State of the World's Nursing (SoWN) 2020 ko te hē o te horapa o te kāhui kaimahi tapuhi puta noa i te ao, otirā i ngā whenua whiwhinga pūtea-nui, whenua kua eke ki ngā taumata whanaketanga, tētahi ārai nui mo te whāinga mātua o ngā Whāinga Whanaketanga Toitū o te Huihuinga o ngā Whenua o te Ao, me te Ropū Hauora o te Ao E kī ana ngā kupu tohutohu kaupapa here o te pūrongo SoWN he mea nui te haumitanga ki te whakatupu i te kāhui kaimahi tapuhi, kāpā kia whakatikaina te korenga tapuhi 5 9 miriona huri noa i te ao, engari hei whakapiki i te whakaputanga tapuhi i te wā kāinga i ngā whenua e whakawhirinaki atu ana ki ngā tapuhi kua whakangungua i tāwāhi He whenua a Aotearoa e whakawhirinaki atu ana ki ngā tapuhi i whai tohu i tāwāhi, arā, 27 orau o te kāhui kaimahi tapuhi he tangata no whenua kē Ko ngā tohutohu matua o te pūrongo ko te haumi ki ngā raraunga kāhui kaimahi tapuhi me ona whakahaere;ngā mahi hautū i te ao tapuhi;te mātauranga tapuhi;me ngā whakaritenga ā-ture mo ngā tapuhi Tā tēnei pūrongo he hora whakamaherehere hāngai mo te kaha rawa o te whakawhirinaki ki ngā tapuhi o tāwāhi i ēnei rā o te mate urutā o KOWHEORI-19, te paheketanga ohaoha, me te kakenga nui o te koremahi Me mātua whakaoti tētahi rautaki tapuhi ā-motu whai take hei whakatikatika i to Aotearoa kaha whakawhirinaki atu ki ngā tapuhi no whenua kē Me whakahāngai tēnei mahi hira ki te whakapikinga o ngā putanga hauora taupori, me te whakaheke i ngā putanga tino rerekē mo tēnā wehenga mo tēnā wehenga o te taupori Ahakoa ēnei mea katoa, kei te ngū tonu te pūrongo SoWN mo te kāhui tapuhi iwi taketake ā-ao, me te hauora iwi taketake Hei whakatikatika i tēnei hapa nui, me tahuri Aotearoa ki te whakapiki i te korenga e orite o te iwi Māori i tona kāhui kaimahi mā te haumi ki te whakapikinga i te kāinga nei o gā tapuhi Māori, tae atu ki ngā āheinga me ngā pūmanawa o ngā kaihautū tapuhi Māori, hei mea e heke ai te korenga e orite o te hauora o te iwi Māori Ki te kore e tika te haumi ki te whakaputanga i te kāinga o te kāhui kaimahi tapuhi i Aotearoa i tēnei wā, ka kīa he takahanga i te tika kia whakawhirinaki kau atu ki ngā kāhui taetae mai o ngā tapuhi whai tohu no ngā whenua o tāwāhi Ka noho ko ngā urupare arotake i te Pūrongo hei mea whai hua mo Aotearoa me ngā kaipānui tapuhi o te ao
世界卫生组织的《2020年世界护理状况》报告指出,护理人员的国际分布不均,特别是在高收入国家和发达国家,联合国可持续发展目标和世界卫生组织全民健康覆盖的优先事项受到严重阻碍。《世界健康状况报告》中的政策建议强调投资于增加护理人员队伍,不仅要解决国际上估计的590万名护士短缺问题,但为了在那些过度依赖海外培训护士的国家增加国内护士的生产,新西兰就是一个严重依赖国际合格护士的国家,报告提出的主要建议包括投资于护理人员数据及其管理、护理领导、护理教育和护士监管。报告就严重过度依赖移民护士的问题提供了及时建议,特别是在2019冠状病毒病全球大流行、经济衰退、迫切需要制定一项连贯的国家护理人力战略,以解决新西兰奥特罗阿的护理人力问题。这项重要工作必须与改善人口健康结果和减少令人无法接受的高健康差距率保持一致。然而,该报告几乎没有提及国际土著护理人力和土著健康问题。新西兰将需要通过投资于Māori护士的国内增长以及Māori护理领导能力和能力,解决Māori在其护理人员队伍中持续存在的不平等现象,以便更好地为减少Māori保健不平等作出贡献。而继续依赖国际合格护士的移民将是不道德的,这种对世界护理状况报告的批评性回应将对新西兰和国际护理受众有价值。另一个摘要:我把k / a放在pūrongo 2020年世界护理状况(s / s)中,在kāhui kaimahi tapuhi puta noa I ao, otirā I ngā whenua whwhinga pūtea-nui, whenua kua eke ki ngā taumata whanaketanga,tētahiārai努伊莫te whā印加mā图阿āo ng whā印加Whanaketanga原先ūāo te Huihuinga o ng Whenua te Ao阿,我特罗普ūHauora o te Ao E kī安娜ngākupu tohutohu kaupapa o te pūrongo播种他mea nui te haumitanga ki te whakatupu我te kā回族kaimahi tapuhi, kāpā起亚whakatikaina te korenga tapuhi 5 9 miriona来源于丰沛诺亚我te Ao,engari hei whakapiki whakaputanga tapuhi whakaputanga tapuhi whakaputangi wā kāinga i ngā whenua e whakawhirinaki atu ana ki ngā tapuhi kua whakangungui tāwāhi他whenua a Aotearoa e whakawhirinaki atu ana ki ngā tapuhi whai tohu i tāwāhi, arā,27 orau kāo te回族kaimahi tapuhi他新西兰没有whenua kēKo ngātohutohu呢o te pūrongo Ko te haumi ki ngāraraunga kā回族kaimahi tapuhi我ona whakahaere; ngāmahi上流社会的ū我te ao tapuhi; te mā陶兰加tapuhi;我ngāwhakaritengaā真正莫ngātapuhi Tāēnei pūrongo他赫拉whakamaherehere hāngai莫te kaha rawaāo te whakawhirinaki ki ng tapuhi Tāo wā嗨我ēnei rāo te伴侣urutāo KOWHEORI-19 te paheketanga ohaoha,我te kakenga nuiāo te koremahi我米图阿whakaoti tētahi rautaki tapuhiā莫土语whai花喜whakatikatika我长白云之乡kaha whakawhirinaki前提ki ngātapuhi没有whenua kē我whakahāngai tēnei mahi希拉ki te whakapikingaāo ng putanga hauora taupori, te whakaheke我ngāputanga帝诺rerekē莫tēnāwehenga莫tēnāo wehenga te taupori Ahakoaēnei mea katoa,祺te ngūtonu te pūrongo播种莫te kā回族tapuhi艾维taketakeāao,我te hauora艾维taketake黑whakatikatika我tēnei hapa努伊,我tahuri长白云之乡ki te whakapiki我te korenga e orite o te艾维āori我tona kā回族kaimahi Māte haumi ki te whakapikinga我te kāo gā印加nei tapuhi Māori tae前提ki ngāāheinga我ngāpūmanawaāo ng kaihautūtapuhi Mā并用,黑mea e heke ai te korenga e oriteāo te hauora o te艾维米ori ki te科莱e tika te haumi ki te whakaputanga我te kāo te印加kā回族kaimahi tapuhi我长白云之乡ēnei w tā,ka kuta takahanga i the tika kia whakawhirinaki kau atu ki ngā kāhui taetae mai o ngā tapuhi whakawhirinaki kau atu ki ngā kāhui taetae mai o ngā tapuhi whakawhirinaki kau atu ki ngā whenua o tāwāhi ka noho ko ngā urupare arotake i the Pūrongo hei me whaihua mo Aotearoa me ngā kaipānui tapuhi o the ao