O. Mongan, O. Tummon, S. Lydon, Emily O’Dowd, Lyle Mc Vicker, P. Marren, D. Byrne
{"title":"PG72 An evaluation of the efficacy of a SAFMEDS intervention to train dermatology diagnostic skills in junior doctors","authors":"O. Mongan, O. Tummon, S. Lydon, Emily O’Dowd, Lyle Mc Vicker, P. Marren, D. Byrne","doi":"10.1136/BMJSTEL-2020-ASPIHCONF.120","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Introduction Upon qualifying, many physicians have inadequate exposure to dermatology and lack confidence in their dermatology skills(1,2). Accurate diagnosis of skin conditions requires clinical exposure over a long period of time. Precision teaching is an educational method used to develop fluency (defined as accuracy with speed). SAFMEDS (Say All Fast Minute Every Day Shuffled’) is a precision teaching technique that uses flashcards to develop fluency in the learner Method The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of SAFMEDS as an adjunct to experiential learning and traditional dermatology teaching on the diagnostic skills of doctors in their first year after graduation from medical school. This study used a pragmatic between-groups randomised controlled trial design. Following consent, participants completed a baseline assessment followed by a one-hour dermatology lecture. They were then randomised to control group or intervention group. The intervention group received a pack of SAFMEDS flashcards with 68 images of 17 common dermatological conditions (image on the front and correct diagnosis on the back). Following training in the technique, they were asked to complete at least one SAFMEDS trial per day and document their results. On reaching fluency, (defined by expert performance as 26 correct answers with 0 or 1 incorrect per one minute) or the pre-determined end-of-study date, the intervention group participants completed a post-test. Control group participants also completed the post-test. The intervention group completed a retention test 6–8 weeks later. Results Of the 30 who consented to take part, 15 were randomised to the control group and 15 to the intervention group. Results showed a medium effect size with significantly greater improvement in scores of the intervention group (mean score at baseline: 49.9%, at post-test: 73.74%) as compared to the control group (mean score at baseline: 48.86%, at post-test: 55.43%). Performance of the intervention group persisted at the retention test. Discussion and Conclusion Test scores improved significantly in the intervention group and persisted for 6 weeks after the intervention stopped. SAFMEDS offers an effective, time-efficient and feasible adjunct to traditional dermatology teaching and may be particularly useful for postgraduates who have competing demands on their time. References Shah H, Pozo-Garcia L, & Koulouroudias M. ( 2015).:Dermatology – a compulsory part of the UK medical school curriculum?Medical Education Online;20(1):30212. Kelly A, Hennessy C, Ryan C. Unsatisfactory Level of Undergraduate Dermatology Education in Newly Qualified Irish Doctors. Ir Med J 2018;111(4):746.","PeriodicalId":44757,"journal":{"name":"BMJ Simulation & Technology Enhanced Learning","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":1.1000,"publicationDate":"2020-11-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"BMJ Simulation & Technology Enhanced Learning","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1136/BMJSTEL-2020-ASPIHCONF.120","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"Social Sciences","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Introduction Upon qualifying, many physicians have inadequate exposure to dermatology and lack confidence in their dermatology skills(1,2). Accurate diagnosis of skin conditions requires clinical exposure over a long period of time. Precision teaching is an educational method used to develop fluency (defined as accuracy with speed). SAFMEDS (Say All Fast Minute Every Day Shuffled’) is a precision teaching technique that uses flashcards to develop fluency in the learner Method The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of SAFMEDS as an adjunct to experiential learning and traditional dermatology teaching on the diagnostic skills of doctors in their first year after graduation from medical school. This study used a pragmatic between-groups randomised controlled trial design. Following consent, participants completed a baseline assessment followed by a one-hour dermatology lecture. They were then randomised to control group or intervention group. The intervention group received a pack of SAFMEDS flashcards with 68 images of 17 common dermatological conditions (image on the front and correct diagnosis on the back). Following training in the technique, they were asked to complete at least one SAFMEDS trial per day and document their results. On reaching fluency, (defined by expert performance as 26 correct answers with 0 or 1 incorrect per one minute) or the pre-determined end-of-study date, the intervention group participants completed a post-test. Control group participants also completed the post-test. The intervention group completed a retention test 6–8 weeks later. Results Of the 30 who consented to take part, 15 were randomised to the control group and 15 to the intervention group. Results showed a medium effect size with significantly greater improvement in scores of the intervention group (mean score at baseline: 49.9%, at post-test: 73.74%) as compared to the control group (mean score at baseline: 48.86%, at post-test: 55.43%). Performance of the intervention group persisted at the retention test. Discussion and Conclusion Test scores improved significantly in the intervention group and persisted for 6 weeks after the intervention stopped. SAFMEDS offers an effective, time-efficient and feasible adjunct to traditional dermatology teaching and may be particularly useful for postgraduates who have competing demands on their time. References Shah H, Pozo-Garcia L, & Koulouroudias M. ( 2015).:Dermatology – a compulsory part of the UK medical school curriculum?Medical Education Online;20(1):30212. Kelly A, Hennessy C, Ryan C. Unsatisfactory Level of Undergraduate Dermatology Education in Newly Qualified Irish Doctors. Ir Med J 2018;111(4):746.
在获得资格后,许多医生对皮肤科的接触不足,对他们的皮肤科技能缺乏信心(1,2)。准确诊断皮肤状况需要长时间的临床暴露。精确教学是一种培养流利性的教育方法(定义为准确性和速度)。safmed (Say All Fast Minute Every Day shuffed)是一种精确的教学方法,使用抽抽卡来培养学习者的流畅性。本研究的目的是评估safmed作为体验式学习和传统皮肤病学教学的辅助手段,对医学院毕业后第一年医生诊断技能的影响。本研究采用实用的组间随机对照试验设计。在获得同意后,参与者完成了基线评估,随后进行了一小时的皮肤病学讲座。然后将他们随机分为对照组和干预组。干预组收到一套SAFMEDS抽抽卡,其中有17种常见皮肤病的68张图像(正面为图像,背面为正确诊断)。在技术培训之后,他们被要求每天至少完成一次safmed试验并记录他们的结果。在达到流利程度(专家表现定义为每分钟26个正确答案,0或1个错误答案)或预先确定的学习结束日期后,干预组参与者完成后测试。对照组的参与者也完成了后测。干预组在6-8周后完成记忆保留测试。在30名同意参与研究的人中,15人被随机分配到对照组,15人被随机分配到干预组。结果显示,与对照组(基线平均评分48.86%,后测55.43%)相比,干预组(基线平均评分49.9%,后测73.74%)得分的改善具有中等效应。干预组在记忆保留测试中的表现保持不变。讨论与结论干预组测试成绩明显提高,并在干预停止后持续6周。safmed为传统皮肤病学教学提供了一种有效、高效和可行的辅助手段,对那些时间紧迫的研究生尤其有用。参考文献Shah H, Pozo-Garcia L, & Koulouroudias M.(2015)。皮肤病学-英国医学院课程的必修部分?医学教育在线;20(1):30212。Kelly A, Hennessy C, Ryan C.新合格的爱尔兰医生的皮肤病学本科教育水平不理想。中华医学杂志,2018;31(4):746。