Performance Analysis of ACO and FA Algorithms on Parameter Variation Scenarios in Determining Alternative Routes for Cars as a Solution to Traffic Jams

Abstract

This study proposes several alternative optimal routes on traffic-prone routes using Ant Colony Optimization (ACO) and Firefly Algorithm (FA). Two methods are classified as the metaheuristic method, which means that they can solve problems with complex optimization and will get the solution with the best results. Comparison of alternative routes generated by the two algorithms is measured based on several parameters, namely alpha and beta in determination of the best alternative route. The results obtained are that the alternative route produced by FA is superior to ACO, with an accuracy of 88%. This is also supported by the performance of the FA algorithm which is generally superior, where the resulting alternative route is shorter in distance, time, running time and  there is no influence on the alpha parameter value. But in each iteration, the number of alternative routes generated is less. The contribution of this research is to provide information about the best algorithm between ACO and FA in providing the most optimal alternative route based on the fastest travel time. The recommended alternative path is a path that is sufficient for cars to pass, because the selection takes into account the size of the road capacity.