Revisiting the subalpine Mesolithic site Ullafelsen in the Fotsch Valley, Stubai Alps, Austria – new insights into pedogenesis and landscape evolution from leaf-wax-derived n-alkanes, black carbon and radiocarbon dating
M. Zech, M. Lerch, M. Bliedtner, Tobias Bromm, Fabian Seemann, S. Szidat, G. Salazar, R. Zech, B. Glaser, J. Haas, D. Schäfer, C. Geitner
{"title":"Revisiting the subalpine Mesolithic site Ullafelsen in the Fotsch Valley, Stubai Alps, Austria – new insights into pedogenesis and landscape evolution from leaf-wax-derived n-alkanes, black carbon and radiocarbon dating","authors":"M. Zech, M. Lerch, M. Bliedtner, Tobias Bromm, Fabian Seemann, S. Szidat, G. Salazar, R. Zech, B. Glaser, J. Haas, D. Schäfer, C. Geitner","doi":"10.5194/EGQSJ-70-171-2021","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Abstract. Archaeological research in high mountain regions has gotten a lot more attention since\nthe discovery of the copper age mummy called “Ötzi” in the Ötztaler\nAlps in 1991. In the Tyrolean Stubai Alps, the Mesolithic site Ullafelsen at\n1869 m a.s.l. (above sea level) close to the recent upper timberline in the Fotsch Valley\nrepresents, on the one hand, a very important archaeological reference site\nand offers, on the other hand, intriguing research questions related to, amongst\nothers, pedogenesis. Given that no biomarkers and stable isotopes\nhave been hitherto investigated, we aimed at contributing with respective analyses and\nadditional radiocarbon dating to a better understanding of the landscape\nevolution and pedogenesis on and around the Ullafelsen. Our results for modern vegetation suggest that leaf-wax-derived n-alkanes\nallow us to chemotaxonomically distinguish between subalpine deciduous trees\n(nC27 predominance) versus (sub)alpine grasses, herbs and dwarf shrubs\n(nC29, nC31 and/or nC33 predominance). Except for Juniperus, conifers\nproduce no or extremely low n-alkane contents. Although no clear vegetation\nchanges could be inferred from the n-alkane patterns of the investigated soil\nprofiles, the total n-alkane content (TAC) was developed for the first time\nas an unambiguous proxy for distinguishing between buried (= fossil) topsoils\n(2Ahb horizons) and humus-enriched subsoils such as Bh horizons of podzols.\nBased on this leaf wax proxy, we can rule out that the 2Ahb?/Bh? horizons\nunder question on the Ullafelsen are buried topsoils as suggested\npreviously. Dating of the H2O2-pretreated soil samples yielded\n14C ages for the podzol Bh horizons ranging from 6.7 to 5.4 cal kyr BP. This is clearly younger than the overlying Mesolithic living floor (LL)\n(10.9 to 9.5 cal kyr BP) but pre-dates the assumed intensification of\nalpine pasturing from the Bronze Age onwards. Both the LL and the directly\noverlying OAh3 horizon yielded black carbon maxima and benzene\npolycarboxylic acid patterns reflecting fire-induced human impact during the\nMesolithic. The discrepancy between the Mesolithic charcoal 14C ages\n(ages of ≥ 9.5 cal kyr BP) versus the 14C ages obtained for bulk\nn-alkanes ranging from 8.2 to 4.9 cal kyr BP suggests that non-alkane-producing conifers predominated the vegetation on and around the Ullafelsen\nafter the Mesolithic occupation. Only with the anthropo-zoological lowering\nof the timberline associated with alpine pasturing since the Neolithic and\nespecially the Bronze Age has an n-alkane-producing vegetation cover (grasses,\nherbs or dwarf shrubs) started to predominate.\n","PeriodicalId":11420,"journal":{"name":"E&G Quaternary Science Journal","volume":"28 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2021-07-13","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"3","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"E&G Quaternary Science Journal","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.5194/EGQSJ-70-171-2021","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 3
Abstract
Abstract. Archaeological research in high mountain regions has gotten a lot more attention since
the discovery of the copper age mummy called “Ötzi” in the Ötztaler
Alps in 1991. In the Tyrolean Stubai Alps, the Mesolithic site Ullafelsen at
1869 m a.s.l. (above sea level) close to the recent upper timberline in the Fotsch Valley
represents, on the one hand, a very important archaeological reference site
and offers, on the other hand, intriguing research questions related to, amongst
others, pedogenesis. Given that no biomarkers and stable isotopes
have been hitherto investigated, we aimed at contributing with respective analyses and
additional radiocarbon dating to a better understanding of the landscape
evolution and pedogenesis on and around the Ullafelsen. Our results for modern vegetation suggest that leaf-wax-derived n-alkanes
allow us to chemotaxonomically distinguish between subalpine deciduous trees
(nC27 predominance) versus (sub)alpine grasses, herbs and dwarf shrubs
(nC29, nC31 and/or nC33 predominance). Except for Juniperus, conifers
produce no or extremely low n-alkane contents. Although no clear vegetation
changes could be inferred from the n-alkane patterns of the investigated soil
profiles, the total n-alkane content (TAC) was developed for the first time
as an unambiguous proxy for distinguishing between buried (= fossil) topsoils
(2Ahb horizons) and humus-enriched subsoils such as Bh horizons of podzols.
Based on this leaf wax proxy, we can rule out that the 2Ahb?/Bh? horizons
under question on the Ullafelsen are buried topsoils as suggested
previously. Dating of the H2O2-pretreated soil samples yielded
14C ages for the podzol Bh horizons ranging from 6.7 to 5.4 cal kyr BP. This is clearly younger than the overlying Mesolithic living floor (LL)
(10.9 to 9.5 cal kyr BP) but pre-dates the assumed intensification of
alpine pasturing from the Bronze Age onwards. Both the LL and the directly
overlying OAh3 horizon yielded black carbon maxima and benzene
polycarboxylic acid patterns reflecting fire-induced human impact during the
Mesolithic. The discrepancy between the Mesolithic charcoal 14C ages
(ages of ≥ 9.5 cal kyr BP) versus the 14C ages obtained for bulk
n-alkanes ranging from 8.2 to 4.9 cal kyr BP suggests that non-alkane-producing conifers predominated the vegetation on and around the Ullafelsen
after the Mesolithic occupation. Only with the anthropo-zoological lowering
of the timberline associated with alpine pasturing since the Neolithic and
especially the Bronze Age has an n-alkane-producing vegetation cover (grasses,
herbs or dwarf shrubs) started to predominate.
摘要自1991年在ÖtztalerAlps发现铜器时代的木乃伊“Ötzi”以来,高山地区的考古研究受到了越来越多的关注。在蒂洛尔斯图拜阿尔卑斯山脉,1869米的中石器时代遗址Ullafelsen。(海平面以上)靠近最近的Fotsch山谷的上树带界线,一方面代表了一个非常重要的考古参考地点,另一方面,提供了与其他方面有关的有趣的研究问题,其中包括,土壤形成。鉴于迄今为止还没有研究过生物标志物和稳定同位素,我们的目标是通过各自的分析和额外的放射性碳定年来更好地了解Ullafelsen及其周围的景观演化和土壤形成。我们对现代植被的研究结果表明,叶蜡衍生的正烷糖使我们能够在化学分类上区分亚高山落叶乔木(nC27优势)与(亚)高山草、草本和矮灌木(nC29、nC31和/或nC33优势)。除了杜松,针叶树不产生或极低的正构烷烃含量。虽然从所研究的土壤剖面的正构烷烃模式不能推断出明显的植被变化,但总正构烷烃含量(TAC)首次被发展为区分埋藏(=化石)表土(2Ahb层)和富含腐殖质的底土(如灰化土的Bh层)的明确代理。根据叶蜡替代物,我们可以排除2Ahb?/Bh?如前所述,Ullafelsen上被质疑的水平是被掩埋的表层土壤。经h2o2预处理的土壤样品的测年结果表明,灰化土Bh层的14c年龄在6.7 ~ 5.4 cal kyr BP之间。这显然比上覆的中石器时代生活层(LL)(10.9至9.5千万年BP)更年轻,但早于青铜时代以后阿尔卑斯牧场的强化。LL和直接覆盖的OAh3层都产生了黑碳最大值和苯聚羧酸模式,反映了新石器时代人类对火的影响。中石器时代木炭14C年龄(≥9.5 cal kyr BP)与块状烷烃14C年龄(8.2 ~ 4.9 cal kyr BP)之间的差异表明,中石器时代占领后,乌拉菲尔森及其周围的植被主要是不产烷烃的针叶树。只有在新石器时代,特别是青铜时代,与高山放牧有关的人类动物降低了树带线之后,产生正构烷烃的植被(草、草本植物或矮灌木)才开始占主导地位。