Self-deliberation and the Strategy of the Pseudo-dialogue

Abstract

* Ph.D. in Philosophy from the University of Waterloo. Director, Centre for Research in Reasoning, Argumentation and Rhetoric, & Professor, Department of Philosophy University of Windsor, Canada. orcid: 0000-00022820-1416 Abstract The New Rhetoric identifies the self-deliberator as one of three main types of audience. But such a turn toward the self is at odds with studies of contemporary argumentation, particularly social argumentation. Argumentation takes place “out there”, modifying the environments in which audiences operate. Equally interesting is the use of self-deliberation as a rhetorical strategy. Arguing with oneself, especially when that self is distanced in some way from the individual involved, employs self-deliberation beyond the ends that Perelman assigned to it. In this paper, my goal is to explore the nature of the self-deliberator as an audience and selfdeliberation as a rhetorical strategy employed in argumentation.