The SGML/XML Approach to Document Processing: [an incomplete] History of Criticisms and Challenges

Abstract

Like all SGML/XML enthusiasts I have spent considerable energy responding to objections to the SGML/XML approach to document processing. In this talk I list some objections to that approach that have been posed by authors, scholars, designers, philosophers, clients, programmers, web designers, and computer scientists, and indicate how I (and others) have responded — that includes responses that in the interest of sustaining friendships or job security were never quite articulated. I look forward to your additions in the discussion.