{"title":"From Alle Oder Keiner (All or No One)","authors":"Ulrich Peltzer, W. Martin","doi":"10.2307/25304946","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"In retrospect I think I must have seen her first at Schonefeld, at one of the check-in counters, as Ruhle and I and the rest of the German delegates, from Koln, Braunschweig, and Essen, were standing to the side; we had just met and introduced ourselves and were waiting for our boarding call, in German and English, rather than how it used to be in German and Russian or some other Slavic language, even if the flight was in the opposite direction-to Barcelona via Prague on CSA, the tickets you could get for unbeatable bucket-shop prices at a travel agency on Uhlandstratge run by the West-Berlin Socialist Unity Party, cheaper than the twenty-four-hour direct train, a Vietnamese man sitting next to me on the plane, a reddish-gold badge with the image of Ho Chi Minh on it pinned to the broad lapel of his suit, stoically spooning breaded fish off the aluminum foil: two-hundred-sixty marks roundtrip, or to Rome on Interflug for almost as little: once you were out of hard-currency territory or had the right passport the state-owned airlines would transport you for practically nothingnow all of that was over, gone under, swallowed up by the competition, they even renovated the airport here to conform to Western standards, with moving walkways and cocktail bars in the terminal, and no more unnecessary frisking at the security gate, or attentive reading of notes half-forgotten in a pants' pocket, I think I remember having seen her there already, in front of the new check-in counters, after Rihle had introduced me to his colleagues as a member of his research team, on tiptoe, her arms around the neck of a man whose appearance escapes me now, except that he was a little taller than she was, briefly affirming their relationship, that they would still be together, and she was wearing, if this is really what happened, her black raincoat and washed-out jeans, and had, but this I'm sure of, medium-length, reddish-brown hair, lovers, taking leave of each other, putting off their leavetaking even longer, a commonplace in airports, at train stations, before the open tailboard of ferries. Then I stopped paying attention to them, the boarding call came, and our group, together with our luggage, briefcases, and duty-free bags, began moving forward. Supported by funds from international organizations-Unesco and the EU-the Bucharest conference was intended to provide, in addition to its regular program, Romanian government officials with a view into the workings of West European forensics; they had set up special panels at which academics and jurists would be available to discuss their respective countries' legal procedures for determining a given defendant's capacity for criminal activity. In the plane I sat beside a young psychiatrist who had just finished his dissertation at the Essen Institute and had once read something of mine, an article on obstacles in assessment procedures, which he brought up, apparently interested in my work; he was scouring court proceedings from the fifties, which, he said, knitting his brow and laughing caustically, were both theoretically and terminologically sheer nazism, so much crap about spiritual inferiority and hereditary asociality, about genetic causes for mental deficiency and psychopathological malice, you wouldn't believe it if it wasn't there in black and white, and in terms of personnel, it was pretty grim then, too, all those people who managed to keep their teaching jobs after the war and continued educating generations of students, not all that different, I said, with the psychologists, who either became hard-nosed behaviorists or went off to develop their race theories in the jungle, shooting pictures of darkskinned natives. His boss and Ruhle were talking with each other in the row in front of us, we could see the backs of their heads, and occasionally a face in half-profile when one of them turned to look at the paper the other was holding. We were served Romanian wine with the meal, a remarkably good wine, we both agreed, as if that fact needed to be confirmed, was hardly to be expected, to the contrary, although it wasn't anything in particular, a vague impression gleaned from television images, press reports, and half-forgotten information learned at school, and which colored one's perceptions, one's taste, the same as with subjects of experiments who've been given only certain data, negative or positive, telling them that someone is insane as opposed to relaxed, or that a color is garish rather than pretty; what did we know about Romania, a dotted outline on a political map and, of course, the grotesque dictatorship of a party secretary who together with his wife ended up slumped at the base of a wall, riddled with bullets, broadcast in a blurry video image. …","PeriodicalId":42508,"journal":{"name":"CHICAGO REVIEW","volume":"48 1","pages":"234"},"PeriodicalIF":0.1000,"publicationDate":"2002-07-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://sci-hub-pdf.com/10.2307/25304946","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"CHICAGO REVIEW","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.2307/25304946","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"文学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"LITERARY REVIEWS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
In retrospect I think I must have seen her first at Schonefeld, at one of the check-in counters, as Ruhle and I and the rest of the German delegates, from Koln, Braunschweig, and Essen, were standing to the side; we had just met and introduced ourselves and were waiting for our boarding call, in German and English, rather than how it used to be in German and Russian or some other Slavic language, even if the flight was in the opposite direction-to Barcelona via Prague on CSA, the tickets you could get for unbeatable bucket-shop prices at a travel agency on Uhlandstratge run by the West-Berlin Socialist Unity Party, cheaper than the twenty-four-hour direct train, a Vietnamese man sitting next to me on the plane, a reddish-gold badge with the image of Ho Chi Minh on it pinned to the broad lapel of his suit, stoically spooning breaded fish off the aluminum foil: two-hundred-sixty marks roundtrip, or to Rome on Interflug for almost as little: once you were out of hard-currency territory or had the right passport the state-owned airlines would transport you for practically nothingnow all of that was over, gone under, swallowed up by the competition, they even renovated the airport here to conform to Western standards, with moving walkways and cocktail bars in the terminal, and no more unnecessary frisking at the security gate, or attentive reading of notes half-forgotten in a pants' pocket, I think I remember having seen her there already, in front of the new check-in counters, after Rihle had introduced me to his colleagues as a member of his research team, on tiptoe, her arms around the neck of a man whose appearance escapes me now, except that he was a little taller than she was, briefly affirming their relationship, that they would still be together, and she was wearing, if this is really what happened, her black raincoat and washed-out jeans, and had, but this I'm sure of, medium-length, reddish-brown hair, lovers, taking leave of each other, putting off their leavetaking even longer, a commonplace in airports, at train stations, before the open tailboard of ferries. Then I stopped paying attention to them, the boarding call came, and our group, together with our luggage, briefcases, and duty-free bags, began moving forward. Supported by funds from international organizations-Unesco and the EU-the Bucharest conference was intended to provide, in addition to its regular program, Romanian government officials with a view into the workings of West European forensics; they had set up special panels at which academics and jurists would be available to discuss their respective countries' legal procedures for determining a given defendant's capacity for criminal activity. In the plane I sat beside a young psychiatrist who had just finished his dissertation at the Essen Institute and had once read something of mine, an article on obstacles in assessment procedures, which he brought up, apparently interested in my work; he was scouring court proceedings from the fifties, which, he said, knitting his brow and laughing caustically, were both theoretically and terminologically sheer nazism, so much crap about spiritual inferiority and hereditary asociality, about genetic causes for mental deficiency and psychopathological malice, you wouldn't believe it if it wasn't there in black and white, and in terms of personnel, it was pretty grim then, too, all those people who managed to keep their teaching jobs after the war and continued educating generations of students, not all that different, I said, with the psychologists, who either became hard-nosed behaviorists or went off to develop their race theories in the jungle, shooting pictures of darkskinned natives. His boss and Ruhle were talking with each other in the row in front of us, we could see the backs of their heads, and occasionally a face in half-profile when one of them turned to look at the paper the other was holding. We were served Romanian wine with the meal, a remarkably good wine, we both agreed, as if that fact needed to be confirmed, was hardly to be expected, to the contrary, although it wasn't anything in particular, a vague impression gleaned from television images, press reports, and half-forgotten information learned at school, and which colored one's perceptions, one's taste, the same as with subjects of experiments who've been given only certain data, negative or positive, telling them that someone is insane as opposed to relaxed, or that a color is garish rather than pretty; what did we know about Romania, a dotted outline on a political map and, of course, the grotesque dictatorship of a party secretary who together with his wife ended up slumped at the base of a wall, riddled with bullets, broadcast in a blurry video image. …
回想起来,我想我第一次见到她一定是在舍内菲尔德机场的一个登记柜台,当时我和鲁勒以及其他来自科隆、不伦瑞克和埃森的德国代表都站在旁边;我们刚刚见过面,自我介绍了一下,正等着我们的登机电话,用德语和英语,而不是像过去那样用德语和俄语或其他斯拉夫语,即使航班是在相反的方向——乘坐CSA经布拉格飞往巴塞罗那,你可以在西柏林社会主义团结党经营的Uhlandstratge上的一家旅行社以无与伦比的低价买到票,比24小时直达火车便宜。飞机上坐在我旁边的一个越南人,他宽大的西装翻领上别着一枚红金色的徽章,上面印着胡志明(Ho Chi Minh)的形象,沉着地从铝箔上舀起裹有面包屑的鱼:往返260马克,或者乘坐Interflug去罗马,花费几乎一样少。一旦你离开硬通货区,或者持有正确的护照,国有航空公司就会免费运送你。现在,所有这一切都结束了,破产了,被竞争吞没了,他们甚至把这里的机场重新改造成符合西方标准的机场,在航站楼里安装了移动走道和鸡尾酒吧,安检门不再有不必要的搜身,也不再仔细阅读被遗忘在裤子口袋里的笔记。我想我记得曾经见过她,在新的值机柜台面前,在Rihle把我介绍给他的同事作为他的研究小组的一员,踮起脚尖,怀里的脖子,他的外表现在逃脱我,除了他是一个小比她高,肯定他们的关系,他们还能够在一起,她穿着,如果这是真的发生了什么,她黑色的雨衣和褪色的牛仔裤,,,但我相信,中等长度,红褐色头发,恋人,彼此告别,甚至推迟他们的告别时间,在机场,在火车站,在开放的渡轮尾板前,这是司空见惯的。然后我不再注意他们了,登机的电话响了,我们一行人带着我们的行李、公文包和免税包开始往前走。在联合国教科文组织和欧盟等国际组织的资金支持下,布加勒斯特会议旨在为罗马尼亚政府官员提供一个了解西欧法医学工作的机会。它们设立了专门小组,让学者和法学家讨论各自国家确定某一被告犯罪活动能力的法律程序。在飞机上,我坐在一位年轻的精神病学家旁边,他刚刚在埃森研究所完成了他的论文,曾经读过我的一些东西,一篇关于评估程序障碍的文章,他提到了,显然对我的工作很感兴趣;他在翻查五十年代的法庭诉讼,他皱着眉头,讥讽地笑着说,从理论上和术语上讲,这些都是纯粹的纳粹主义,有那么多关于精神自卑和遗传的社会关系的废话,关于精神缺陷和精神病理恶意的基因原因的废话,如果不是白纸黑字,你不会相信的,而且在人员方面,当时也相当严峻,那些人在战后保住了他们的教学工作,继续教育一代又一代的学生,我说,与那些心理学家没有太大的不同,他们要么变成了精明的行为主义者,要么去丛林里发展他们的种族理论,拍摄深色皮肤的土著人。他的老板和鲁勒在我们前面一排交谈,我们可以看到他们的后脑勺,偶尔当他们中的一个人转过身去看另一个人拿着的报纸时,我们可以看到他们的半侧脸。这顿饭给我们端上了罗马尼亚酒,我们都认为,这是一种非常好的酒,好像这是需要证实的,是很难预料到的,恰恰相反,虽然这不是什么特别的东西,只是一种从电视画面、新闻报道和在学校里学到的半遗忘的信息中得来的模糊印象,这种印象影响了人的感觉,影响了人的品味,就像实验对象只得到某些消极或积极的数据一样,告诉他们某人很疯狂而不是很放松,或者某种颜色很花哨而不是很漂亮;我们对罗马尼亚的了解是什么,政治地图上的一个虚线轮廓,当然,还有一个党委书记的怪诞独裁统治,他和他的妻子最后瘫倒在墙脚上,满身是子弹,在一个模糊的视频图像中播出。…
期刊介绍:
In the back issues room down the hall from Chicago Review’s offices on the third floor of Lillie House sit hundreds of unread magazines, yearning to see the light of day. These historic issues from the Chicago Review archives may now be ordered online with a credit card (via CCNow). Some of them are groundbreaking anthologies, others outstanding general issues.