A generalized application of the catch-curve regression with comparisons of adult mortality and year-class strength between hatchery-stocked and wild-reared lake trout in US waters of Lake Huron

Abstract

The recently developed approach to estimating instantaneous total mortality of coded-wire-tagged lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush) is generally applicable to catch-at-age data. We further formalized the technique to objectively incorporate the year-class and year effects into the model structure of catch-curve regression. We used this new method to compare adult mortality and year-class strength between the hatchery-stocked and wild-reared lake trout in US waters of Lake Huron, one of the Laurentian Great Lakes. Model comparisons showed no difference in adult mortality between the hatchery-stocked and wild-reared lake trout. Based on 95% confidence intervals, the estimate of adult mortality using the simple catch-curve regression with average number-at-age was not statistically different from the estimate using the linear-mixed model with individual number-at-age of multiple year-classes and sampling years. The linear-mixed model, however, also quantified lake trout year-class strength and indicated that since 2003 the increases in recruitment of wild-reared lake trout did not fully compensate for the rapid declines in recruitment of hatchery-stocked lake trout in Lake Huron.