Blameworthiness, Control, and Consciousness Or A Consciousness Requirement and an Argument For It

Abstract

: I first clarify the idea that blameworthiness requires consciousness as the view that one can be blameworthy only for what is a response to a reason of which one is conscious. Next I develop the following argument: blameworthiness requires exercising control in a way distinctive of persons and doing this, in view of what it is to be a person, requires responding to a reason of which one is conscious.Then I defend thisargumentfrom an objectioninspired byArpalyand Schroeder according to which responding to moral reasons suffices for exercising control distinctive of persons.