Dalla tavola al touch (e ritorno). Rimediazioni tra fumetto cartaceo e digitale in Leo Ortolani = From paper page to touchscreen (and back). Remediations between printed and digital comics in Leo Ortolani
{"title":"Dalla tavola al touch (e ritorno). Rimediazioni tra fumetto cartaceo e digitale in Leo Ortolani = From paper page to touchscreen (and back). Remediations between printed and digital comics in Leo Ortolani","authors":"Alessio Aletta","doi":"10.1285/I22840753N18P209","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"On the basis of Bolter and Grusin's definition of 'remediation' as 'the representation of one medium in another', this paper analyses the various ways in which digital comics have tried to rethink the comics 'grid' for computers and smaller devices, following three main approaches: digitalized comic, 'infinite canvas' and 'panel delivery'. In particular, this study discusses the problems that may arise when comics created for the screen are published on paper (an issue which is much less explored in the literature). The analysis focuses on the interactions between 'traditional' and digital comics in the latest works of Italian cartoonist Leo Ortolani. Over the last few years this author, despite being famous mostly for having created the popular superhero parody Rat-man, has experimented a variety of different approaches on e-comics. Most recently, Ortolani worked on a series of 'mobile comics' in which he chronicled the developing of Covid's first wave in the Spring of 2020. This series was later published in a volume titled Andra tutto bene ('Everything will be fine'), which imitates the original 'panel delivery' format by printing one panel per page. This peculiar typographical choice, which seems to embody the very idea of 'remediation', muddles the separation between 'traditional' paper comics and e-comics. Furthermore, by trying to preserve the 'mobile comic' layout, Ortolani seems to legitimize the peculiarity of e-comics as an independent medium with its own potentialities.","PeriodicalId":40441,"journal":{"name":"H-ermes-Journal of Communication","volume":"2020 1","pages":"209-228"},"PeriodicalIF":0.2000,"publicationDate":"2020-07-12","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"H-ermes-Journal of Communication","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1285/I22840753N18P209","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"COMMUNICATION","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
On the basis of Bolter and Grusin's definition of 'remediation' as 'the representation of one medium in another', this paper analyses the various ways in which digital comics have tried to rethink the comics 'grid' for computers and smaller devices, following three main approaches: digitalized comic, 'infinite canvas' and 'panel delivery'. In particular, this study discusses the problems that may arise when comics created for the screen are published on paper (an issue which is much less explored in the literature). The analysis focuses on the interactions between 'traditional' and digital comics in the latest works of Italian cartoonist Leo Ortolani. Over the last few years this author, despite being famous mostly for having created the popular superhero parody Rat-man, has experimented a variety of different approaches on e-comics. Most recently, Ortolani worked on a series of 'mobile comics' in which he chronicled the developing of Covid's first wave in the Spring of 2020. This series was later published in a volume titled Andra tutto bene ('Everything will be fine'), which imitates the original 'panel delivery' format by printing one panel per page. This peculiar typographical choice, which seems to embody the very idea of 'remediation', muddles the separation between 'traditional' paper comics and e-comics. Furthermore, by trying to preserve the 'mobile comic' layout, Ortolani seems to legitimize the peculiarity of e-comics as an independent medium with its own potentialities.
在Bolter和Grusin将“补救”定义为“一种媒介在另一种媒介中的表现”的基础上,本文分析了数字漫画试图重新思考计算机和小型设备的漫画“网格”的各种方式,以下三种主要方法:数字化漫画,“无限画布”和“面板交付”。特别地,本研究讨论了当为屏幕创作的漫画在纸上出版时可能出现的问题(这个问题在文献中很少探讨)。分析的重点是意大利漫画家Leo Ortolani的最新作品中“传统”和数字漫画之间的相互作用。在过去的几年里,这位作者虽然以模仿超级英雄鼠人而出名,但他在电子漫画上尝试了各种不同的方法。最近,奥尔托拉尼创作了一系列“移动漫画”,在这些漫画中,他记录了2020年春季新冠病毒第一波的发展。这个系列后来出版了一卷名为Andra tutto bene(“一切都会好的”),它模仿了原始的“面板交付”格式,每页打印一个面板。这种独特的排版选择似乎体现了“补救”的理念,混淆了“传统”纸质漫画和电子漫画之间的区分。此外,通过尝试保留“移动漫画”的布局,Ortolani似乎将电子漫画作为一种具有自身潜力的独立媒体的特性合法化。