The Macro- and Microphysical Response Characteristics of the Multicell Hailstorm Hail-Suppression Operation: Case Study

Abstract

This study analyzed the macro- and microphysical response characteristics of a typical multicell hailstorm after seeding on 27 April 2019 in Weining, China, using X-band dual-polarization radar (YLD1-D) data. An improved X-pol hydrometeor identification algorithm was employed for hydrometeor identification. According to the diffusion of the seeding agents, the seeded hailstorm was graded into three study regions, and the evolution of the seeded hailstorm was divided into four periods. The response characteristics of the seeded hailstorm in each region and period were compared and analyzed. The results show that 1) macroscopically, the decrease in the reflectivity and the height of strong echo mainly occurred in the seeded period, whereas the decrease in the echo top and the height of the storm was mainly in the postseeded period; the echo height variation of the unseeded hailstorm is obviously different from that of the seeded hailstorm; and 2) from the microscopic perspective, the decrease in low-density graupel and supercooled water and the increase in ice crystals and aggregates in the seeded region mainly occurred in the seeded period, which was consistent with the time required for the “benefit competition” after the silver iodide completed nucleation. When compared with the seeded region, the hydrometeors in the unseeded region had an opposite trend (or an in-phase trend with an obviously lower changing rate), which further indicated the impact of the artificial ice nuclei on microphysical processes in the seeded region. For hailstorms with a high content of supercooled droplets and graupel, the key mechanisms of hail suppression are “cloud water glaciation,” “beneficial competition,” and “early rainout.”