Terminal Illness and Compassionate Release

Abstract

International prisoners can apply for early release. However, terminally ill prisoners seeking release in the international criminal justice system face significant legal and practical obstacles. This is particularly the case for prisoners convicted by the International Criminal Court (ICC): there is currently no framework for granting compassionate release prior to serving the statutory required amount of a sentence. To build a foundation for recommendations for the creation of a system of compassionate release at the ICC, this article critically examines the systems used to grant early release to terminally ill persons in international (International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals) and national criminal law, with a particular focus on how these systems operate for prisoners that have served less than the typical eligibility requirement for release. This article sets out a normative basis for creating a novel and distinct form of release at the ICC: a compassionate system based, not on penological justifications, but on the impossibility of continued detention on human rights grounds. It concludes with recommendations for essential substantial and procedural elements for this system and means of incorporating it into the current legal framework.