{"title":"Romanesque Tomb Effigies: Death and Redemption in Medieval Europe, 1000–1200","authors":"Jessica Barker","doi":"10.1080/00681288.2023.2234761","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"liturgical season. It must have created a spectacle in great contrast with the more fixed, muted, aged-pine interior greeting today’s visitor. The remaining four chapters each address the carvings on the building’s interior stave capitals, another unique aspect of this building which reveals glimpses of 12th-century cultural exchange. The contrasting perspectives offered here by Kirk Ambrose, Thomas Dale, Elizabeth den Hartog and Kjartan Hauglid examine the iconography through various lenses and connect the visual language of this corner of Norway with Mediterranean and Islamic cultures, presenting an international or even cosmopolitan view of medieval Urnes. The absence of a conclusion to the book is suggestive of its aim of offering a platform upon which future research can build, rather than providing answers. It makes a significant departure from previous publications, predominantly written by Scandinavian male authors, whose gaze has constructed a particular understanding of the building. Here new contributions from a more diverse international perspective afford this perennially intriguing subject a broader range of analysis than has previously been achieved. As proto-preservationist and landscape artist Johan C. Dahl wrote already in 1837, Urnes and particularly its carvings had ‘acquired a sort of mysterious air and a quite peculiar appeal that is due to the still undisclosed secrets surrounding their origin’. Today, that mysteriousness finds itself increasingly commercially exploited. Nevertheless, this academic publication makes an excellent contribution to counterbalancing Urnes’ misappropriation by extending the re-evaluation and re-exploration of those ‘still undisclosed secrets’ further along knowledge-based trajectories.","PeriodicalId":42723,"journal":{"name":"Journal of the British Archaeological Association","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.2000,"publicationDate":"2023-09-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"1","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of the British Archaeological Association","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1080/00681288.2023.2234761","RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"历史学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"ARCHAEOLOGY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 1
Abstract
liturgical season. It must have created a spectacle in great contrast with the more fixed, muted, aged-pine interior greeting today’s visitor. The remaining four chapters each address the carvings on the building’s interior stave capitals, another unique aspect of this building which reveals glimpses of 12th-century cultural exchange. The contrasting perspectives offered here by Kirk Ambrose, Thomas Dale, Elizabeth den Hartog and Kjartan Hauglid examine the iconography through various lenses and connect the visual language of this corner of Norway with Mediterranean and Islamic cultures, presenting an international or even cosmopolitan view of medieval Urnes. The absence of a conclusion to the book is suggestive of its aim of offering a platform upon which future research can build, rather than providing answers. It makes a significant departure from previous publications, predominantly written by Scandinavian male authors, whose gaze has constructed a particular understanding of the building. Here new contributions from a more diverse international perspective afford this perennially intriguing subject a broader range of analysis than has previously been achieved. As proto-preservationist and landscape artist Johan C. Dahl wrote already in 1837, Urnes and particularly its carvings had ‘acquired a sort of mysterious air and a quite peculiar appeal that is due to the still undisclosed secrets surrounding their origin’. Today, that mysteriousness finds itself increasingly commercially exploited. Nevertheless, this academic publication makes an excellent contribution to counterbalancing Urnes’ misappropriation by extending the re-evaluation and re-exploration of those ‘still undisclosed secrets’ further along knowledge-based trajectories.
礼拜仪式的季节。它一定创造了一种奇观,与迎接今天的来访者的更固定、更安静、更古老的松木内饰形成了鲜明的对比。剩下的四章分别讲述了建筑内部的雕刻,这是这座建筑的另一个独特的方面,揭示了12世纪文化交流的一瞥。Kirk Ambrose, Thomas Dale, Elizabeth den Hartog和Kjartan Hauglid通过不同的视角审视了图像,并将挪威这个角落的视觉语言与地中海和伊斯兰文化联系起来,呈现出中世纪乌尔内斯的国际甚至世界主义视角。这本书没有结论,这表明它的目的是为未来的研究提供一个平台,而不是提供答案。它与以前的出版物有很大的不同,这些出版物主要由斯堪的纳维亚男性作家撰写,他们的目光构建了对建筑的特殊理解。在这里,来自更多样化的国际视角的新贡献为这个长期引人入胜的主题提供了比以前更广泛的分析。正如原始保护主义者和风景艺术家约翰·c·达尔在1837年所写的那样,厄恩斯,特别是它的雕刻“获得了一种神秘的气氛和一种非常特殊的吸引力,这是由于围绕它们起源的尚未公开的秘密”。今天,这种神秘感发现自己越来越多地被商业利用。尽管如此,这一学术出版物通过扩展对那些“尚未披露的秘密”的重新评估和重新探索,进一步沿着基于知识的轨迹,为平衡Urnes的盗用做出了卓越的贡献。