The role of forensic and legal systems in suicide prevention: Implications for Israeli healthcare policy.

Abstract

Background: Suicide is a leading cause of death among young people worldwide and remains a significant cause of mortality across all age groups, especially in older adults. The underlying causes of suicide span various disciplines and are deeply influenced by societal attitudes, which fluctuate between glorification and severe condemnation of suicide. This study aims to evaluate the role of court rulings on suicidal behavior, with particular attention to implications for healthcare policy in Israel.

Methods: We searched the national court rulings databases for alleged psychiatry malpractice in suicide-related cases and of pre-trial settlements from 1985 to 2023. For court decisions, we collected patients' socio-demographic and clinical characteristics, lawsuit characteristics, and the quality of medical documentation and decision-making processes. For pre-trial settlements, we collected data about lawsuit characteristics. Two researchers reviewed the qualitative data, while the quantitative data was analyzed with descriptive statistics.

Results: Over the 38-year period, there were 20 psychiatry malpractice court lawsuits related to patient suicides, including 17 deaths and 3 life threatening attempts. Of these, 12 (60%) of cases were won by the plaintiff, and eight (40%) by the defendant. In 14 cases, the suicides occurred in inpatient units and in six cases in community settings. The number of lawsuits notably increased over time for suicide events, with 17 pre-court settlements between 1985 and 1997, and 56 cases in each of the subsequent periods (1998-2010 and 2011-2023).

Conclusions: The number of malpractice lawsuits related to suicide in Israel is increasing over time. Our findings, which show a rise in both litigation and pre-trial settlements, may put pressure on psychiatrists to avoid certain kinds of work, especially in the public sector. Such a shift could have broader effects on the quality of suicide prevention efforts and overall mental health care. The study highlights the structural tension between retrospective legal accountability and prospective clinical and public-health approaches to suicide prevention. Addressing this challenge requires balanced policy responses, including strengthening patient-safety and risk-management systems, improving clinical documentation and decision transparency, fostering constructive collaboration between legal and mental health systems, and considering alternative compensation mechanisms that reduce adversarial pressures while supporting affected families.