Optimising Zooplankton DNA Metabarcoding: Methodological Considerations for Large-Scale Monitoring.

Abstract

DNA metabarcoding is becoming an increasingly common approach in ecological monitoring of marine and freshwater planktonic communities, yet methodological choices along the metabarcoding workflow and data post-processing approaches remain highly inconsistent across studies, limiting the ability to track biodiversity trends, detect range shifts, or integrate datasets across monitoring programs. This study addresses this methodological bottleneck by combining controlled experimental comparisons with a comprehensive literature synthesis to identify how protocol decisions-from sample preservation and DNA extraction to sequencing platforms and taxonomic assignments-affect the results of COI metabarcoding and its interpretation. Overall biodiversity and community patterns were recovered by all combinations of tested methods, supporting the notion that patterns identified through DNA metabarcoding are robust and comparable across studies. We identify TES (Tris-EDTA-SDS) buffer, optionally paired with at-sea homogenisation, as a practical alternative to ethanol preservation for large-scale monitoring surveys. We show that integrating several classification methods and reference databases for taxonomic assignment improves diversity estimates and confidence in the assignments, and advocate for increased use of tools like BOLDigger that facilitate manual curation of ambiguous/erroneous references. Finally, we demonstrate that introducing stricter filtering thresholds reduces the effect of false positives, pseudogenes and lab-specific contamination, and make comparisons of data generated by different laboratories and methodological configurations more robust, although potentially at the expense of excluding rare taxa. While we intentionally refrain from recommending a universal best practices protocol, this study aims to provide a practical roadmap to help enhance the reliability and reproducibility of marine zooplankton monitoring via DNA metabarcoding.