Paramedics' Decisions to Withhold Resuscitation in Traumatic Cardiac Arrest: Accuracy of Paramedic Assessments Compared with Autopsy Findings.

Abstract

Objectives: Trauma remains the leading cause of death among Canadians under 45, with over 70% of these deaths occurring in the prehospital setting. In Ontario, Canada, paramedics' decision to initiate or withhold resuscitation in traumatic cardiac arrest (TCA) is governed by basic life support (BLS) and advanced life support (ALS) patient care standards. This study explores paramedics' decisions to withhold cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) in cases of prehospital TCA.

Methods: We conducted a retrospective review of case files relating to coroner investigations of prehospital TCA across two emergency medical services (EMS) covering a mixed urban/suburban region in Ontario, Canada, with a population of approximately 4.3 million people, from January 2018 to July 2022. We reviewed all deaths where EMS records were available in the death investigation files and where paramedics did not provide CPR. Paramedics' documentation of reasons to withhold CPR was reviewed and compared to postmortem findings. Descriptive statistics were used to describe the findings.

Results: We identified 90 cases of prehospital TCA where no CPR was provided by paramedics. Of these, 55 cases (61%) had documented, injuries incompatible with life (decapitation, open head or torso wounds with visible outpouring of brain or abdominal contents) or signs of irreversible death (rigor mortis, lividity, decomposition). Postmortem examination confirmed paramedics' findings of injuries incompatible with life in 29 cases (89%). For the remaining 35 cases (39%), CPR was withheld due to a combination of prolonged time from TCA to EMS contact, severity of injuries deemed non-survivable, significant external blood loss, and following remote physician agreement in 31 (89%) cases. Of these, 29 (83%) had postmortem findings demonstrating anatomical injuries that made the TCA irreversible.

Conclusions: The majority of decisions to withhold CPR in prehospital TCA cases are based on signs that are clearly incompatible with life, identified by paramedics with high specificity. In the absence of such findings, paramedics consider factors like prolonged time intervals, overall injury severity, and seek guidance through remote physician supervision before deciding whether to withhold resuscitation efforts.