Maddalena Infante, Sara Binotto, Michela Salgaro, Alice Cattoi, Giulia Cavaliere, Marianna Cioni, Piergiorgio Ciraci, Claudia Comencini, Luca Dal Lago, Linda Faccioli, Eleonora Giramonti, Tania Iuriatti, Barbara Mantovan, Marco Reniero, Fabio Rubinato, Giovanni Sartori, Alvisa Palese
{"title":"[The concept of overeducation and its implication for the nursing profession].","authors":"Maddalena Infante, Sara Binotto, Michela Salgaro, Alice Cattoi, Giulia Cavaliere, Marianna Cioni, Piergiorgio Ciraci, Claudia Comencini, Luca Dal Lago, Linda Faccioli, Eleonora Giramonti, Tania Iuriatti, Barbara Mantovan, Marco Reniero, Fabio Rubinato, Giovanni Sartori, Alvisa Palese","doi":"10.1702/4664.46764","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>. The concept of overeducation and its implication for the nursing profession. Beyond salary-related issues, limited social recognition and the insufficient valorisation of competencies acquired through post-basic education or advanced professional experience also play a significant role in the attractiveness of the nursing profession. The concept of overeducation in this context refers to the mismatch between the level of education attained and the role actually performed. Despite its growing relevance, this concept still lacks a clear theoretical and operational framework, particularly within nursing.A narrative literature review was conducted using PubMed, Web of Science, and grey literature sources, including contributions from economic and sociological research to analyse definitions, measurement approaches, causes, and consequences of overeducation, as well as related concepts such as overskilling, skill mismatch, and overqualification.Published papers adopt different definitions making comparisons difficult. Overeducation may take individual or collective forms and can be either temporary or persistent, with economic, organisational, and professional determinants. It may impact on job dissatisfaction, turnover intentions, burnout, and the underutilisation of human capital, but it may also prompt proactive strategies for professional mobility. Measuring overeducation in nursing requires first clarifying how the concept can be operationalized within a profession where advanced education does not always correspond to formally differentiated roles. Studying overeducation becomes essential to understand the alignment between training, recognition of credentials, and the effective use of professional competencies. This involves defining appropriate indicators that capture the alignment between educational attainment, role requirements, and the actual use of competencies in practice.</p>","PeriodicalId":516320,"journal":{"name":"Assistenza infermieristica e ricerca : AIR","volume":"45 1","pages":"36-41"},"PeriodicalIF":0.9000,"publicationDate":"2026-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Assistenza infermieristica e ricerca : AIR","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1702/4664.46764","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
. The concept of overeducation and its implication for the nursing profession. Beyond salary-related issues, limited social recognition and the insufficient valorisation of competencies acquired through post-basic education or advanced professional experience also play a significant role in the attractiveness of the nursing profession. The concept of overeducation in this context refers to the mismatch between the level of education attained and the role actually performed. Despite its growing relevance, this concept still lacks a clear theoretical and operational framework, particularly within nursing.A narrative literature review was conducted using PubMed, Web of Science, and grey literature sources, including contributions from economic and sociological research to analyse definitions, measurement approaches, causes, and consequences of overeducation, as well as related concepts such as overskilling, skill mismatch, and overqualification.Published papers adopt different definitions making comparisons difficult. Overeducation may take individual or collective forms and can be either temporary or persistent, with economic, organisational, and professional determinants. It may impact on job dissatisfaction, turnover intentions, burnout, and the underutilisation of human capital, but it may also prompt proactive strategies for professional mobility. Measuring overeducation in nursing requires first clarifying how the concept can be operationalized within a profession where advanced education does not always correspond to formally differentiated roles. Studying overeducation becomes essential to understand the alignment between training, recognition of credentials, and the effective use of professional competencies. This involves defining appropriate indicators that capture the alignment between educational attainment, role requirements, and the actual use of competencies in practice.
. 过度教育的概念及其对护理专业的启示。除了与工资相关的问题外,有限的社会认可和通过后基础教育或高级专业经验获得的能力的不充分增值也对护理专业的吸引力起着重要作用。在这种情况下,过度教育的概念是指所获得的教育水平与实际发挥的作用之间的不匹配。尽管其相关性越来越大,但这一概念仍然缺乏明确的理论和操作框架,特别是在护理领域。我们使用PubMed、Web of Science和灰色文献来源(包括来自经济学和社会学研究的贡献)进行了一项叙述性文献综述,以分析过度教育的定义、测量方法、原因和后果,以及相关概念,如过度技能、技能不匹配和过度资格。发表的论文采用了不同的定义,使得比较变得困难。过度教育可以采取个人或集体的形式,可以是暂时的,也可以是持续的,这与经济、组织和专业的决定因素有关。它可能对工作不满、离职意向、倦怠和人力资本利用不足产生影响,但它也可能促使积极主动的职业流动策略。衡量护理中的过度教育首先需要澄清如何在一个高级教育并不总是对应于正式区分的角色的职业中实现这一概念。研究过度教育对于理解培训、证书认可和有效利用专业能力之间的一致性至关重要。这包括定义适当的指标,以捕获教育成就、角色要求和实践中能力的实际使用之间的一致性。