Master's Degree Nurses: A Mixed-Methods Study on Supply, Demand, and Utilisation.

Abstract

AIMS To assess the supply, demand, and utilisation of master's degree nurses in China's top-tier hospitals and identify recruitment and retention challenges. DESIGN A convergent parallel mixed-methods design. METHODS From January and September 2022, eight top-tier hospitals in mainland China were selected using convenience sampling. The proportion of master's degree nurses, turnover rates, and recruitment outcomes were investigated and analysed using descriptive statistics. Concurrently, seven nursing administrators from these eight hospitals were interviewed using semi-structured interviews, and transcribed data were thematically analysed through inductive content analysis. RESULTS Among the eight hospitals surveyed, the average proportion of master's degree nurses was 3.58% (range: 0.58%-9.43%). The average ratio of planned to actual recruitment was 3.28, with four hospitals showing near parity (approximately 1:1) and three institutions failing to recruit any master's degree nurses. The annual turnover rate of master's degree nurses was 1.18%. Three themes emerged from the qualitative analysis: (1) shortages coexisting with oversupply; (2) nursing leaders' retention efforts versus limited institutional policy support; and (3) prioritisation of research and management over advanced clinical roles. CONCLUSION In China, even among top-tier hospitals, the proportion of master's degree nurses remains relatively low. There is an overall shortage of these nurses, juxtaposed with localised oversupply in specific institutions. Promotion to nursing supervisor or administrative roles is the only developmental pathway, while structured career progression pathways for advanced nursing practice remain conspicuously absent. IMPLICATIONS FOR THE PROFESSION AND/OR PATIENT CARE The study highlights the need to develop targeted policies that support the career advancement of master's degree nurses, particularly by expanding career options in Advanced Practice Nurses (APNs) rather than limiting roles to nursing management or education. This shift would better leverage their clinical expertise and strengthen healthcare systems through specialised practice and innovation. IMPACT What problem did the study address?: This study maps the supply-demand dynamics of master's degree nurses in leading hospitals and identifies retention, utilisation, and motivation policies and strategies from the perspective of nursing administrators. What were the main findings?: The proportion of master's degree nurses is low in China's top hospitals. There is both an oversupply and a shortage of master's degree nurses. Neither the government nor hospitals have policies in place to encourage the clinical involvement of master's degree nurses, and their career progression is limited to managerial roles. Where and on whom will the research have an impact?: Nursing administrators and other health policy makers in China and comparable global health systems will be affected. It will also influence nursing associations, nursing educators, and general nurses. REPORTING METHODS This study adhered to the Mixed Methods Article Reporting Standards. PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION No contributions from patients or the public were involved in this study.