Effect of Prolonged Use of Different Facemasks on Their Physical Performance and Physiological Impact on the Wearer

Abstract

Background

Most published studies on potential facemask physical performances and physiological impairments had shorter observation periods, and the observed occupational physical activities had limited relevance to real occupational work. Thus, our study aimed to assess the impact of prolonged mask use on its physical performances and the associated physiological responses in wearers.

Methods

The recruitment of study participants took place between November 2022 and March 2023. Facemask penetration and breathing resistance measurements were obtained at 4 and 8 hours using the TSI Model 8130 Automated Filter Tester and the INSPEC Breathing Resistance Rig. Facial skin temperature and transepidermal water loss were quantified using thermal imaging cameras and vapometers, respectively.

Results

A total of 216 workers participated in the study. A significant reduction in penetration (p < 0.001, partial Ƞ² = 0.1) and an increase in breathing resistance (p < 0.001, partial Ƞ² = 0.9) were observed only in case of surgical masks worn by cleaners after 8 hours. Facial skin temperature increased after 8 hours for KF94 (p < 0.001, partial Ƞ² = 0.2), surgical mask (p < 0.001, partial Ƞ² = 0.4), and cloth mask (p < 0.001, partial Ƞ² = 0.2). All three facemasks had a statistically significant interaction with use on facial skin temperature. Higher transepidermal water loss was only observed for the cloth mask (F (p = 0.034, partial Ƞ² = 0.02).

Conclusion

Our findings suggest that prolonged use of face masks can lead to a deterioration in penetration, breathing resistance, and physiological impairment for the mask wearer. The implications are particularly critical for high–occupational activity jobs requiring prolonged use of masks.