Cobalt toxicity from third-body wear following revision of fractured ceramic-on-ceramic hip bearings with a metal articulation : the fractured ceramic syndrome.

Abstract

Aims: Ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC) articulations in total hip arthroplasty (THA) have the advantage of low wear but the unique risk of fracture. After revision for CoC-bearing fracture, third-body ceramic particles can lead to massive wear of cobalt-chrome (CoCr) bearings, causing extremely elevated blood cobalt. We present a multicentre series of five cases where patients sustained fractures of ceramic liners, were revised using a CoCr articulation, and rapidly developed severe cobalt toxicity.

Methods: We identified five cases of cobalt toxicity after fractured CoC THA treated with revision to CoCr on polyethylene bearings. Mean follow-up was three years (5 to 72 months) after re-revision to remove the CoCr bearing.

Results: Symptoms of cobalt toxicity occurred at a mean ten months (6 to 12) after revision for ceramic fracture. All patients developed vision and hearing loss, balance difficulties, and peripheral neuropathy. Several had cardiomyopathy, endocrine abnormalities, and local skin discolouration. Only two reported hip pain. Repeat revision for recognized cobalt toxicity occurred at a mean 22 months after revision for ceramic fracture. Mean serum cobalt level at re-revision was 991 ng/ml (normal value < 1 ng/ml; 734 to 1,302). All CoCr femoral heads exhibited massive wear, and deep tissues showed prominent metal staining. Treatment consisted of debridement and revision to a ceramic femoral head with highly cross-linked polyethylene (HXLPE) liner. Serum cobalt improved to a mean 25 μg/l (1 to 76) at final follow-up. All patients reported partial improvement in vision and hearing, however their peripheral neuropathy and balance difficulties did not recover.

Conclusion: Systemic cobalt toxicity is a devastating complication of ceramic-bearing fracture in THA treated with CoCr bearings, which may not present with hip symptoms. The diagnosis of this syndrome of systemic cobalt toxicity was significantly delayed following systemic symptoms in this series. Debridement and re-revision to a ceramic-on-HXLPE bearing leads to improvement, but not full resolution, of cobalt toxicity complications.