Cross-Education Effects of Unilateral Knee-Extensor Strength Training in Patients With Knee Osteoarthritis: A Critically Appraised Topic.

Abstract

Clinical scenario: Knee-extensor strength training is commonly used in patients with knee osteoarthritis (KOA) to improve muscle function, mobility, and quality of life. For typical complaints that result in significant movement limitation or even immobilization, unilateral knee-extensor strength training of the unaffected or less affected limb to induce a cross-education (CE) effect in the contralateral affected limb may be a possible but understudied treatment option.

Focused clinical question: Does unilateral knee-extensor strength training lead to CE effects in the contralateral affected limb in patients with KOA?

Summary of key findings: Results from 2 randomized controlled/clinical trials (level 1b) and 1 quasi-experimental study (level 2) provided limited grade B evidence for the CE effect of unilateral knee-extensor strength training to improve maximal knee-extensor strength of the affected limb in patients with KOA.

Clinical bottom line: Based on the current literature, unilateral knee-extensor strength training induces a significant CE effect in the contralateral affected limb by increasing maximal knee-extensor muscle strength in patients with KOA, but there is no consensus on the exact nature of the adaptations and whether different types of muscle contractions during training are superior to each other.

Strength of recommendation: Due to limited evidence (grade B), the true CE effect of unilateral knee-extensor strength training of the unaffected or less affected limb to improve maximal knee-extensor strength of the contralateral affected limb in patients with KOA remains unclear and needs further investigation.