Countywide burden, pathology, and genetics of lethal hypertrophic cardiomyopathy: from the POST SCD study.

Abstract

Aims: Incidence of sudden cardiac death (SCD) is 1%/year in cohorts with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM), but this estimate presumes arrhythmic cause and misses occult cases dying before diagnosis.

Methods and results: POST SCD (POstmortem Systematic InvesTigation of Sudden Cardiac Death) is a prospective cohort study using autopsy, clinical records, and toxicology to adjudicate arrhythmic or non-arrhythmic causes among presumed SCDs (pSCDs) meeting WHO criteria aged 0-90 years in San Francisco County. We included all incident cases 2/1/2011-3/1/2014 (n = 525) and approximately every third day 3/1/2014-9/1/2022 (n = 497) based on medical examiner call schedule. We identified HCM victims via three approaches: (i) pathology; (ii) echocardiogram [transthoracic echocardiogram (TTE)]; (iii) genetic criteria. Incidence calculations used county data and estimated HCM prevalence of 1:500 from studies of persons aged 23-35 years old. Of 1022 pSCDs [558 (54.6%) arrhythmic deaths] during the study period, 13 had HCM: 10 met pathology criteria; 2 via review of 203 TTEs (missed on initial report); 1 via genetic testing. Of these, 11 were arrhythmic deaths, yielding 1.3% burden of sudden death (pSCD) and 2% of arrhythmic death. Only 2 of 13 (15%) pSCDs with HCM had pre-mortem diagnosis. Incidence for persons with HCM 18-35 years old was 0.2% pSCDs/year and 0.1% SADs/year. pSCDs with HCM had a higher proportion of arrhythmic cause [11/13 (85%) vs. 547/1009 (54%), P = 0.03] than those without. pSCD burden due to HCM decreased with age (P = 0.003), highest among victims <35 years old, for whom HCM accounted for 7.1% of pSCD and 9.4% of arrhythmic death. Genetic testing of 317 consented pSCDs yielded pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in 40% (2/5) and identified one additional case without clinical phenotype.

Conclusion: In this 11-year countywide post-mortem study, HCM meeting pathologic, clinical, or genetic criteria was associated with autopsy-confirmed arrhythmic cause of sudden death, accounting for 2% of SADs up to age 90, highest in cases <35 years old. Since 85% of cases were undiagnosed before pSCD, the true burden of HCM-related sudden death may be substantially underestimated.