Time-independent disease state identification defines distinct trajectories determined by localised vs systemic inflammation in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis.

Abstract

Objectives: Patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) display different trajectories towards improvement of disease. We aimed to disentangle the heterogeneity of RA disease trajectories from the first clinical visit onwards using graph-based pseudotime analysis.

Methods: We studied early patients with RA over 1.5 years in 2 data sets: Leiden (Netherlands), n = 1237, with 5017 visits, and Towards a Cure for Early Rheumatoid Arthritis (TACERA) (United Kingdom), n = 243, with 750 visits. We created a pipeline for time-independent clustering of clinical and haematologic features to identify disease states. Sequence analyses of these states defined the trajectories. We studied the predictability of the trajectories with baseline features.

Results: Clustering identified 8 disease states with localised inflammation (joints) and systemic inflammation (erythrocyte sedimentation rate [ESR] or leucocytes) as the main discriminating factors. The disease state sequences consisted of 4 trajectories, which we independently replicated in TACERA: A, high ESR; B, rapid progression from many inflamed joints towards remission; C, high leucocytes; and D, many inflamed joints with poor prognosis. Systemic vs local inflammation patterns showed moderate predictability at baseline (sensitivity of 71% and precision of 0.73 for trajectory A, although lower precision of 0.52 for trajectory B), while other trajectories were less predictable. Trajectories C and D had strong resemblance with B at baseline but deteriorated into less favourable trajectories. Patients in trajectory A were more often female and on average older. The trajectories were not explained by time till disease-modifying antirheumatic drug, baseline disease activity, or symptom duration. The suboptimal trajectories coincided with worse patient-reported outcomes, even when the inflammation was mainly systemic.

Conclusions: We identified 4 distinct trajectories in early RA, differentiating RA into localised vs systemic inflammation. Our results highlight potential differences in disease pathology and opportunities for further targeted treatment. Inevitably, patterns without linkage to our selected features could not be detected.