Hypomorphic RAG2 Deficiency Promotes Selection of Self-Reactive B Cells.

Abstract

Reduced function or hypomorphic variants in recombination-activating genes (RAG) 1 or 2 result in a broad clinical phenotype including common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) and even adult-onset disease. Milder RAG variants are less characterized. Here we describe the longitudinal course of a milder combined RAG deficiency in 3 of 7 siblings sharing the same RAG2 mutations over a 50-year study. Whole-genome and repertoire sequencing, bacteriophage immunizations, and deep immunophenotyping were used to compare affected and unaffected family members. The clinical phenotype of three affected siblings with hypomorphic RAG deficiency ranged from combined immunodeficiency and early mortality to a late-onset CID with hyper-IgM phenotype. T cells were remarkably similar across affected siblings, yet CDR3 skewing and regulatory T cell defects were not observed. B cell analysis showed elevated unswitched CD27+ and CD21^low cells as well as features of an autoreactive antibody repertoire and presence of secreted autoantibodies, yet no clinical autoimmunity was present. Most striking was an expanded polyclonal marginal zone-like B cell population (IgM+IgD+CD27+) utilizing the self-reactive unmutated VH4-34 receptor demonstrating that hypomorphic RAG deficiency can promote expansion of self-reactive B cells. This process, however, was not sufficient to trigger clinical autoimmunity. Utilizing multiple approaches, we functionally measured the specific RAG2 variant effects and assessed how selection and secondary triggers altered the BCR repertoire and immunophenotype overtime. Overall, we demonstrate a broad disease spectrum in siblings with identical hypomorphic RAG deficiency, highlighting that phenotypic divergence can result from expansion of IgM + memory B cells.