Michael Schomaker, Helen McIlleron, Paolo Denti, Iván Díaz
{"title":"Causal Inference for Continuous Multiple Time Point Interventions.","authors":"Michael Schomaker, Helen McIlleron, Paolo Denti, Iván Díaz","doi":"10.1002/sim.10246","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>There are limited options to estimate the treatment effects of variables which are continuous and measured at multiple time points, particularly if the true dose-response curve should be estimated as closely as possible. However, these situations may be of relevance: in pharmacology, one may be interested in how outcomes of people living with-and treated for-HIV, such as viral failure, would vary for time-varying interventions such as different drug concentration trajectories. A challenge for doing causal inference with continuous interventions is that the positivity assumption is typically violated. To address positivity violations, we develop projection functions, which reweigh and redefine the estimand of interest based on functions of the conditional support for the respective interventions. With these functions, we obtain the desired dose-response curve in areas of enough support, and otherwise a meaningful estimand that does not require the positivity assumption. We develop <math> <semantics><mrow><mi>g</mi></mrow> <annotation>$$ g $$</annotation></semantics> </math> -computation type plug-in estimators for this case. Those are contrasted with g-computation estimators which are applied to continuous interventions without specifically addressing positivity violations, which we propose to be presented with diagnostics. The ideas are illustrated with longitudinal data from HIV positive children treated with an efavirenz-based regimen as part of the CHAPAS-3 trial, which enrolled children <math> <semantics><mrow><mo><</mo> <mn>13</mn></mrow> <annotation>$$ <13 $$</annotation></semantics> </math> years in Zambia/Uganda. Simulations show in which situations a standard g-computation approach is appropriate, and in which it leads to bias and how the proposed weighted estimation approach then recovers the alternative estimand of interest.</p>","PeriodicalId":21879,"journal":{"name":"Statistics in Medicine","volume":" ","pages":"5380-5400"},"PeriodicalIF":1.8000,"publicationDate":"2024-12-10","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Statistics in Medicine","FirstCategoryId":"3","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1002/sim.10246","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"医学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"2024/10/17 0:00:00","PubModel":"Epub","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"MATHEMATICAL & COMPUTATIONAL BIOLOGY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
There are limited options to estimate the treatment effects of variables which are continuous and measured at multiple time points, particularly if the true dose-response curve should be estimated as closely as possible. However, these situations may be of relevance: in pharmacology, one may be interested in how outcomes of people living with-and treated for-HIV, such as viral failure, would vary for time-varying interventions such as different drug concentration trajectories. A challenge for doing causal inference with continuous interventions is that the positivity assumption is typically violated. To address positivity violations, we develop projection functions, which reweigh and redefine the estimand of interest based on functions of the conditional support for the respective interventions. With these functions, we obtain the desired dose-response curve in areas of enough support, and otherwise a meaningful estimand that does not require the positivity assumption. We develop -computation type plug-in estimators for this case. Those are contrasted with g-computation estimators which are applied to continuous interventions without specifically addressing positivity violations, which we propose to be presented with diagnostics. The ideas are illustrated with longitudinal data from HIV positive children treated with an efavirenz-based regimen as part of the CHAPAS-3 trial, which enrolled children years in Zambia/Uganda. Simulations show in which situations a standard g-computation approach is appropriate, and in which it leads to bias and how the proposed weighted estimation approach then recovers the alternative estimand of interest.
对于连续性变量和在多个时间点测量的变量,估算其治疗效果的方法很有限,尤其是在需要尽可能接近真实剂量-反应曲线的情况下。然而,这些情况可能与此有关:在药理学中,人们可能会感兴趣的是,对于不同药物浓度轨迹等随时间变化的干预措施,艾滋病毒感染者和接受治疗者的结果(如病毒衰竭)会如何变化。对连续干预进行因果推断的一个挑战是,通常会违反正向性假设。为了解决违反正向性假设的问题,我们开发了投影函数,根据各干预措施的条件支持函数重新权衡和定义感兴趣的估计值。有了这些函数,我们就能在有足够支持度的区域获得所需的剂量-反应曲线,否则就能获得不需要正相关假设的有意义的估计值。在这种情况下,我们开发了 g $$ g $$ 计算型插件估计器。这些估算器与 g 计算估算器形成了鲜明对比,后者适用于连续干预,但不专门处理违反正相关性的情况,我们建议将其与诊断一起提出。我们使用 CHAPAS-3 试验中以依非韦伦为基础的治疗方案治疗的 HIV 阳性儿童的纵向数据来说明我们的想法,该试验在赞比亚/乌干达招募了 13 美元的儿童。模拟显示了标准 g 计算方法在哪些情况下是合适的,在哪些情况下会导致偏差,以及拟议的加权估计方法如何恢复感兴趣的替代估计值。
期刊介绍:
The journal aims to influence practice in medicine and its associated sciences through the publication of papers on statistical and other quantitative methods. Papers will explain new methods and demonstrate their application, preferably through a substantive, real, motivating example or a comprehensive evaluation based on an illustrative example. Alternatively, papers will report on case-studies where creative use or technical generalizations of established methodology is directed towards a substantive application. Reviews of, and tutorials on, general topics relevant to the application of statistics to medicine will also be published. The main criteria for publication are appropriateness of the statistical methods to a particular medical problem and clarity of exposition. Papers with primarily mathematical content will be excluded. The journal aims to enhance communication between statisticians, clinicians and medical researchers.