A Neglected Fracture: Treatment and Infection of Seymour Fractures of the Hallux in the Pediatric Population.

Abstract

Introduction: Seymour physeal fractures of the distal phalanx of the Hallux in children are common but rarely described in the literature. There is limited literature investigating how these fractures should be specifically treated. Generally, good results are reported when open fractures are treated with debridement and antibiotics. This large retrospective review evaluates incidence of infection and compares outcomes of various treatments for Seymour physeal fractures of the distal phalanx of the Hallux in children.

Methods: This study included patients ≤18 years of age treated for Seymour fractures of the Hallux between January 1, 2007, and November 20, 2018, at a single tertiary-care urban children's hospital. Demographic, injury, and treatment data were obtained via a retrospective review of electronic medical records, including closed versus open fracture status, time to treatment, and whether antibiotics were prescribed and taken. Initial radiographic imaging was examined by a single attending surgeon for angulation (degrees) and widening (mm). Outcome variables included the development of infection and the rate and success of healing.

Results: One hundred thirty-eight patients were included in our analysis. Most (84/138, 61%) fractures were closed and treated successfully without antibiotics. Treatment for open fractures varied greatly, with many of these fractures undergoing an incision and drainage procedure (I&D) (33/54, 61%) and antibiotic prescription (43/54, 76%). Most (47/54, 87%) open fractures did not develop infection. However, 7/54 open fractures presented with an active infection. Four out of seven (29%) of these fractures did not receive any treatment before infection presentation. Two others who presented with infection both had delayed antibiotics and neither underwent I&D. Fractures that either presented with or developed an infection presented significantly later than those fractures that did not develop infection (P<0.001). Neither angulation nor displacement correlated to the time of healing or development of infection.

Conclusions: In our large cohort, the majority of open Seymour fractures of the Hallux treated in a timely manner did not develop infection, regardless of treatment. However, open fractures that presented multiple days after injury had an increased incidence of infection. Thus, for open fractures, we recommend timely antibiotics and I&D. Closed fractures may be treated conservatively, with no indication for reduction or use of antibiotics.