Disparities in infectious disease-related health care utilization between Medicaid-enrolled American Indians and non-Hispanic Whites-Lessons from the first 16 months of coronavirus disease 2019 and a decade of flu seasons.

Abstract

Objective: To understand why American Indian and Alaskan Native (AIAN) populations have had exceptionally high COVID-19 mortality, we compare patterns of healthcare utilization and outcomes for two serious infectious respiratory diseases-Influenza-like-illness (ILI) and coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)-between American Indian and Alaskan Native (AIAN) populations (as identified in Medicaid data) and non-Hispanic Whites over the 2009-2021 period.

Study setting and design: We select all people under the age of 65 years identified as non-Hispanic White or AIAN in the New York State Medicaid claims data between 2009 and 2021. We analyze data across 10 ILI cohorts (between September 2009 and August 2020) and 4 COVID-19 cohorts (March-June 2020, July-September 2020, October-December 2020, and January-June 2021). We examine mortality and utilization rates using logistic regressions, adjusting for demographic characteristics, prior chronic conditions, and geographic location (including residence near a reservation). We stratify the analysis by rural vs. nonrural counties.

Data sources and analytic sample: We use the New York State Medicaid claims data for the analysis.

Principal findings: We find that even among Medicaid beneficiaries, who are similar in socioeconomic status and identical in health insurance coverage, AIAN populations have much lower rates of use of outpatient services and much higher rates of acute (inpatient and emergency room) service utilization for both ILI and COVID-19 than non-Hispanic Whites. Prior to COVID-19, demographic and health status-adjusted all-cause mortality rates, including from ILI, were lower among American Indians than among non-Hispanic Whites on New York State Medicaid, but this pattern reversed during the COVID-19 pandemic. Both findings are driven by nonrural counties. We did not observe significant differences in all-cause mortality and acute service utilization comparing AIAN to non-Hispanic Whites in rural areas.

Conclusion: The utilization and mortality disparities we identify within the Medicaid population highlight the need to move beyond insurance in addressing poor health outcomes in the American Indian population.