Inter-laboratory variation for urine albumin among laboratories in a Swedish external quality assessment scheme 2005–2023

Abstract

Introduction

Increased albuminuria is associated with elevated mortality. Urine albumin (U-ALB) above 20 mg/L or albumin-to-creatinine ratio (U-ACR) of 3 g/mol are indicative of moderately increased albuminuria. Due to limited standardization among U-ALB methods, diagnosis of increased albuminuria might prove difficult.

Materials and methods

Data from Equalis’s external quality assessment scheme for low U-ALB levels during 2005–2023 were categorized according to manufacturer and divided into central laboratory (CLAB) and point-of-care testing (POCT) methods. Manufacturer median values were compared to total group mean consensus values and manufacturer CV% was compared at different U-ALB levels.

Results

CLAB was generally closer to consensus values and had lower CV% than POCT at U-ALB levels around 20 mg/L. For CLAB, Roche methods were approximately equal to consensus U-ALB, Abbott 4 % above, and Siemens 5 % below. For POCT, HemoCue was 1 % below, Siemens 7 % above, and Abbott 8 % below. For U-Creatinine, all manufacturers generally had a good agreement differing on average by 1–4 % from consensus.

Conclusions

Although U-ALB methods generally meet The National Kidney Disease Education Program (NKDEP) recommendations of method bias less than 13 % and imprecision less than 30 %, differences among manufacturers have increased over the last years, with 2023 showing the largest differences between methods. This highlights the need for guidelines for albuminuria and ACR to take method differences into consideration, but also for implementation of suitable urine reference materials.