UAV or satellites? How to find the balance between efficiency and accuracy in above ground biomass estimation of artificial young coniferous forest?

Abstract

The accurate estimation of Above Ground Biomass (AGB) is the basis for plantation forest carbon trading. This study focused on Picea crassifolia artificial plantations, extracting individual tree crown diameters and heights using Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) data and calculating the individual tree biomass using allometric growth equations. These results were then used to train a satellite image AGB prediction model. In additional, satellite images were resampled to different resolutions to assess the impact of satellite image resolution on model the accuracy. Finally, the model with the highest accuracy among the deep learning algorithms was selected to predicts the AGB within the P. crassifolia plantation forest. The results indicated that the accuracy of single tree crown diameters extracted from P. crassifolia point clouds significantly surpassed those extracted from general point clouds and Crown Height Model (CHM), while the accuracy of the heights extracted from all three sources was similar; RepLKNet outperformed GoogLeNet and ResNet in identifying plantation forest; random forest slightly outperformed XGBoost in the capability of AGB prediction, while the accuracy of the AGB prediction models initially increasd and then decreasd with satellite image resolution, reaching the highest accuracy at a resolution of 50 m. This indicates that the optimal satellite image resolution for estimating the AGB in the study area was affected by scale effects of 50 m. Compared with the combination of satellite data and manual field measurements, the concurrent use of UAVs and satellites offers significant advantages in terms of efficiency and accuracy. UAVs can replace manual sampling for carbon sequestration transactions for plantations.