Effect of machine learning models on clinician prediction of postoperative complications: the Perioperative ORACLE randomised clinical trial

Abstract

Background

Anaesthesiologists might be able to mitigate risk if they know which patients are at greatest risk for postoperative complications. This trial examined the impact of machine learning models on clinician risk assessment.

Methods

This single-centre, prospective, randomised clinical trial enrolled surgical patients aged ≥18 yr. Anaesthesiologists and nurse anaesthetists providing remote telemedicine support reviewed electronic health records with (assisted group) or without (unassisted group) reviewing machine learning predictions. Clinicians predicted the likelihood of postoperative 30-day all-cause mortality and postoperative acute kidney injury (AKI) within 7 days. The primary outcome was area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) for clinician predictions of mortality and AKI, comparing AUROCs between assisted and unassisted assessments.

Results

We analysed 5071 patients (mean [range] age: 58 [18-100] yr; 52% female) assessed by 89 clinicians. Of these, 98 (2.2%) patients died within 30 days of surgery and 450 (11.1%) patients sustained AKI. Clinician predictions agreed with the models more strongly in the assisted vs unassisted group (weighted kappa 0.75 vs 0.62 for death, mean difference: 0.13 [95% CI 0.10–0.17]; and 0.79 vs 0.54 for AKI, mean difference: 0.25 [95% CI 0.21–0.29]). Clinical prediction of death was similar between the assisted (AUROC 0.793) and unassisted (AUROC 0.780) groups (mean difference: 0.013 [95% CI –0.070 to 0.097]; P=0.76). Prediction of AKI had an AUROC of 0.734 in the assisted group vs 0.688 in the unassisted group (difference 0.046 [95% CI –0.003 to 0.091]; P=0.06).

Conclusions

Clinician performance was not improved by machine learning assistance. Further work is needed to clarify the role of machine learning in real-time perioperative risk stratification.

Clinical trial registration

NCT05042804.