Contribution of the Moon-forming Impactor to the Volatile Inventory in the Bulk Silicate Earth

Abstract

The timing and mechanism by which the present-day inventory of life-essential volatiles hydrogen–carbon–nitrogen–sulfur (H–C–N–S) in the bulk silicate Earth (BSE) was established are debated. In this study we have modeled the equilibrium partitioning of H–C–N–S between core, magma ocean (MO), and atmosphere to determine whether the Moon-forming impactor (MFI) was the primary source of volatiles in the BSE. Our findings suggest that the MFI’s core and MO-degassed atmosphere were its primary H–C–N–S reservoirs. Since the MFI likely lost its MO-degassed atmosphere before the giant impact, most of the BSE’s volatiles must come from the small fraction of the MFI’s core which reequilibrated with Earth’s post-impact MO. This implies a high H–C–N–S inventory in the MFI (up to 50% of volatile-rich carbonaceous chondrites) to establish the BSE’s volatile budget. Although isotopic compositions of nonvolatile elements do not rule out the possibility of substantial volatile-rich, carbonaceous material accretion, MFI’s collisional growth from thermally metamorphosed/differentiated planetesimals makes it improbable that it contained ∼50% carbonaceous chondrite equivalent of H–C–N during its differentiation. Therefore, the MFI was unlikely the primary source of volatiles in the BSE. A significant portion of the BSE’s volatile inventory (especially H and C) likely predates the Moon-forming event. To prevent loss to space and segregation into Earth’s core, volatile-bearing materials must be delivered during the final accretion event(s) preceding the Moon-forming event. The substantial size of the proto-Earth at this stage, combined with limited metal–silicate equilibration during the Moon-forming event, facilitated the retention of these volatiles within the BSE.