Predictors of standardized in-service examination performance and residency outcomes in a graduate periodontics program.

Abstract

OBJECTIVES

The American Academy of Periodontology (AAP) annually offers an extensive multiple-choice in-service examination to graduate periodontics programs across North America. The objectives of this study were to assess the influence of learner- and education-related factors on AAP In-service Examination (AIE) performance and determine whether AIE scores predict residency outcomes.

METHODS

AIE scores from 10 periodontics residency classes at a single center were recorded and compared against a panel of learner- and education-related variables using multiple linear regression models. Defined residency outcome measures potentially related to general cognitive ability and knowledge in periodontics and implant dentistry were analyzed against AIE scores using binomial logistic regression.

RESULTS

No evaluated learner- or education-related variable was a statistically significant predictor of AIE score in this study sample. Likewise, AIE score was not a statistically significant predictor of any assessed residency outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

The AAP has performed a tremendous service to periodontics residents and programs by marshaling the leadership and expertise necessary to offer a professionally constructed assessment instrument. However, in the current study sample, no relationship could be identified between AIE score and any outcome, including first-attempt board certification.

IMPLICATIONS

The AAP In-service Committee appears well situated to provide additional leadership focusing on exam implementation, which may enhance AIE value in competency decision making.