Extended benchmark set for lattice parameters of inorganic solids.

Abstract

The development of novel methods in solid-state quantum chemistry necessitates reliable reference data sets for their assessment. The most fundamental solid-state property of interest is the crystal structure, quantified by the lattice parameters. In the last decade, several studies were conducted to assess theoretical approaches based on the agreement of calculated lattice parameters with respect to experiment as a measure. However, most of these studies used a limited number of reference systems with high symmetry. The present work offers a more comprehensive reference benchmark denoted as Sol337LC, which consists of 337 inorganic compounds with 553 symmetry-inequivalent lattice parameters, representing every element of the periodic table for atomic numbers between 1 and 86, except noble gases, the radioactive elements and lanthanoids. The reference values were taken from earlier benchmarks and from measurements at very low temperature or extrapolation to 0 K. The experimental low-temperature lattice parameters were then corrected for zero-point energy effects via the quasi-harmonic approximation for direct comparison with quantum-chemical optimized structures. A selection of standard density functional approximations was assessed for their deviations from the experimental reference data. The calculations were performed with the crystal orbital program CRYSTAL23, applying optimized atom-centered basis sets of triple-zeta plus polarization quality. The SCAN functional family and the global hybrid functional PW1PW, augmented with the D3 dispersion correction, were found to provide closest agreement with the Sol337LC reference data.