Match rate of neurosurgery residents in the United States at their home institution: A comparative analysis of Pre COVID-19, During COVID-19 and Post COVID-19 pandemic

Abstract

Objective

Limitations to medical student clinical rotation opportunities brought on by the pandemic has the potential to exacerbate differences in access to clinical experience between medical schools, and thus impact the distribution of graduates matching into neurosurgical programs nationwide. The utilization of virtual interviews that started after the pandemic are likely here to stay. In this study we seek to evaluate match rates for American (AMGs) and international medical graduates (IMGs) across the 6 most recent academic years, examining specifically the rate of home-institution matching before, during, and after the COVID-19 pandemic.

Methods

All neurological surgery residents for the years 2018–2024 were included in this analysis, with basic information about each resident being collected using publicly available online resources. For any remaining programs where information was not publicly available, program directors were contacted. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS version 26.0 with a level of significance p<0.05.

Results

Of the total of 1271 AMGs, 1005 (79.1 %) matched away from their home institution. When dividing the 6 academic years into 3 subgroups (pre, intra, and post COVID-19), there was no significant variation between the rates of home institution matching (pre=21.0 %, during=20.4 %, post=21.3 %, p=0.740). Similar results were found while assessing IMGs (pre=28.6 %, during=30.8 %, post=32.3 %, p=0.777). Our analysis found no variation in match rates when isolating for gender across the 6 years studied either for AMGs or IMGs. However, overall institute-specific variations were found where some programs showed increased likelihood of home program match (p<0.001).

Conclusion

Preliminary data analysis suggests that contrary to the broader trends seen in other specialties, neurosurgery applicants do not exhibit a significant shift towards matching in closer proximity to their home institutions post COVID-19 pandemic and during the virtual interviews era.