A simple method for assessing the probability of liquefaction of tailings dams

Abstract

In recent years, two tragic accidents in Brazilian tailings dams resulted in a lack of trust in the performance of these structures. This paper aims at proposing a new procedure for estimating the liquefaction risk of existing tailings dams, with the use of well-known probabilistic methods as a valuable tool in the decision-making process for triggering an Emergency Plan. The combination of a rigorous limit equilibrium stability method (Spencer, 1967) and the FOSM probabilistic procedure (Christian et al., 1992) has proved to adequately predict the imminent liquefaction risk of both Fundão and Feijão tailings dams, which recently collapsed in Mariana (2015) and in Brumadinho (2019), both in Minas Gerais State, Brazil. Considering the triggering mechanisms known to have occurred, the estimated probabilities of liquefaction failure at the time of the accidents were 36% for Fundão Dam, and 47% for Feijão Dam. The results show that the risk associated to the collapse of both structures was well above the acceptable level suggested by current standards.