Improvement of image quality for bright-blood image in VISIBLE (volume isotropic simultaneous interleaved bright- and black-blood examination) by using k-space reordering and startup echoes

Abstract

Purpose

A volume isotropic simultaneous interleaved bright- and black-blood examination (VISIBLE) can simultaneously acquire images with suppressed vascular signals (black-blood images) and images without suppression (bright-blood images). We aimed to improve of the bright-blood images by adjusting the k-space filling and using startup echo.

Methods

The k-space arrangement of bright-blood images in the conventional VISIBLE followed a low-to-high frequency order, whereas that in the proposed VISIBLE sequence was in the reversed order, and a startup echo was added. The effects of startup echo on the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) were evaluated using phantoms, considering both white matter (WM) and post-contrast blood. Data from copper sulfate phantoms were acquired in 1D Fourier transform mode using both the conventional and proposed methods of the two VISIBLE sequences. The signal behavior with each sequence was evaluated. Fourteen patients with a total of 21 metastases were included in the study. For each patient, VISIBLE images of both conventional and proposed methods were obtained consecutively after the contrast agent administration. Using clinical images, we conducted a comparison of the SNR and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) for tumors, normal WM, and blood vessels between the conventional and proposed VISIBLE sequences.

Results

There was no significant difference in SNRs for both black- and bright-blood images between the conventional sequence and the proposed sequence with different number of startup echoes, however, the SNR of the proposed sequence decreased with increasing number of startup echoes in both black- and bright-images. The signal behavior of the bright-blood image reached a “steady state” when the startup echo exceeded 20. The SNRs of blood vessels in the bright-blood images did not differ significantly between conventional and proposed VISIBLE sequences. The SNRs of WM in the bright-blood images was significantly larger in the conventional sequence than in the proposed sequence. The SNRs of tumors in bright blood images was significantly larger in the proposed sequence than in the conventional sequence. The CNRs between tumors and WM, vessels and WM in the bright-blood images were significantly higher in the proposed sequence than in the conventional sequence.

Conclusion

The use of the startup echo in combination with the high-to-low frequency k-space ordering method resulted in improved CNR of the bright-blood images in the VISIBLE sequence.