Jude Amechi Nnaka, Victor Udochukwu Ezeike, Kristjan Thompson, Izuchukwu Azuka Okafor
{"title":"Stress from Cadaver Dissection Linked to Learning Conditions: Evidence from Sub-Saharan Africa","authors":"Jude Amechi Nnaka, Victor Udochukwu Ezeike, Kristjan Thompson, Izuchukwu Azuka Okafor","doi":"10.1101/2024.07.09.24310166","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Objective\nThis study examined the relationship between students′ perceptions of cadaver dissection (CD) and some learning conditions during CD. Methods\nThis is a cross–sectional study involving 2968 medical students and graduates exposed to CD at nine countries systematically and proportionally selected from Sub–Saharan African countries based on their ranking on the four World Bank indices of development and education: population, literacy, human capital index (HCI), and human development index (HDI). A self–administered questionnaire was used to collect relevant data on learning conditions during CD experience of the participants, using online channels, including email, Whatsapp, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. Results\nAbout half (48.76%) of the participants perceived CD as stressful, while 51.24% thought otherwise. However, 57% of participants from institutions where a CD session lasts three hours described their experience as stressful, whereas 69.67% of participants whose institution spent one hour in a single CD session agreed that CD is not stressful. Similarly, 60.63% of participants from institutions with a student-donor ratio between 5 to 10 students per cadaver described their experience as ′not stressful′. In comparison, 57.51% of participants from institutions with a student-donor ratio of 10–20 students per donor and 53.80% of participants from institutions with over 20 students per donor described their experience as stressful. Conclusions\nStudents from institutions with CD instructors, shorter CD sessions, and a smaller student-donor ratio are more likely to perceive CD as stress–free. Providing more support for students during CD and reducing time for CD may be an antidote to CD-related stress.","PeriodicalId":501387,"journal":{"name":"medRxiv - Medical Education","volume":"33 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2024-07-10","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"medRxiv - Medical Education","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.09.24310166","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Objective
This study examined the relationship between students′ perceptions of cadaver dissection (CD) and some learning conditions during CD. Methods
This is a cross–sectional study involving 2968 medical students and graduates exposed to CD at nine countries systematically and proportionally selected from Sub–Saharan African countries based on their ranking on the four World Bank indices of development and education: population, literacy, human capital index (HCI), and human development index (HDI). A self–administered questionnaire was used to collect relevant data on learning conditions during CD experience of the participants, using online channels, including email, Whatsapp, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. Results
About half (48.76%) of the participants perceived CD as stressful, while 51.24% thought otherwise. However, 57% of participants from institutions where a CD session lasts three hours described their experience as stressful, whereas 69.67% of participants whose institution spent one hour in a single CD session agreed that CD is not stressful. Similarly, 60.63% of participants from institutions with a student-donor ratio between 5 to 10 students per cadaver described their experience as ′not stressful′. In comparison, 57.51% of participants from institutions with a student-donor ratio of 10–20 students per donor and 53.80% of participants from institutions with over 20 students per donor described their experience as stressful. Conclusions
Students from institutions with CD instructors, shorter CD sessions, and a smaller student-donor ratio are more likely to perceive CD as stress–free. Providing more support for students during CD and reducing time for CD may be an antidote to CD-related stress.
目的:本研究探讨了学生对尸体解剖(CD)的看法与尸体解剖过程中一些学习条件之间的关系。方法这是一项横断面研究,根据人口、识字率、人力资本指数(HCI)和人类发展指数(HDI)这四项世界银行发展和教育指数的排名,从撒哈拉以南非洲国家中按比例系统地选取了九个国家的 2968 名医科学生和毕业生参与研究。通过电子邮件、Whatsapp、Facebook、Instagram 和 Twitter 等在线渠道,采用自填式问卷调查法收集参与者在 CD 体验期间学习条件的相关数据。结果约一半(48.76%)的参与者认为 CD 有压力,而 51.24% 的参与者持相反意见。然而,57%的来自机构的参与者认为他们的经历是有压力的,而69.67%的来自机构的参与者认为他们的经历是没有压力的。同样,60.63%来自学生与捐献者比例为 5 至 10 人/尸体的院校的参与者认为他们的经历 "没有压力"。相比之下,57.51%来自学生与捐献者比例为 10-20 名学生/每具遗体的院校的参与者和 53.80%来自学生与捐献者比例超过 20 名学生/每具遗体的院校的参与者认为他们的经历是有压力的。结论有 CD 指导教师、CD 课时较短、学生与捐赠者比例较小的院校的学生更有可能认为 CD 没有压力。在 CD 期间为学生提供更多支持并缩短 CD 时间可能是缓解 CD 相关压力的良方。