Evaluation of the Scientific Quality and Usability of Digital Dietary Assessment Tools

Abstract

The importance of digital tools for dietary assessment has increased in recent years, both commercially and scientifically. In the field of nutrition research, the digitization of dietary assessment methods presents many opportunities and risks. One of the main challenges is ensuring scientific quality while maintaining good usability. In this context, an evaluation tool was developed based on the guidelines of the European Food Safety Authorization (EFSA; 2009 and 2014), complemented by the usability aspect of health-related applications. This was followed by a literature search concerning the available dietary assessment tools, which were analyzed according to the evaluation criteria. Eight applications were included in the study after reviewing the inclusion and exclusion criteria for the digital tools. A total of thirty-eight requirements in eight main categories were defined for the evaluation, which the best possible dietary assessment tool should meet. The evaluation showed that none of the tested tools currently meet all the defined requirements or categories. The aspects of usability and the accuracy of data collection showed a positive correlation, suggesting a direct link between the two categories and providing an important approach for future developments.