Effect of bone density on the drill-hole diameter made by a cannulated drill bit in cancellous bone

Abstract

Background

When a pilot hole is made prior to a screw's insertion into bone, the same drill bit is used irrespective of the bone quality. However, osteoporotic bone is fragile and this may affect the hole diameter, which is of particular concern in cancellous bone. In this study, the relationship between bone density and drill-hole diameter was investigated assuming a pre-drilling process in screw-only osteosynthesis in the metaphysis and epiphysis.

Methods

Two types of drill bit (triple-flute [T] and quadruple-flute [Q]) with different shapes and diameters were prepared: type T bits with 3.5 mm and 4.4 mm diameters, and type Q bits with 3.5 mm and 4.2 mm diameters. Drilling was performed manually in simulated bones with four densities: 5, 10, 15, and 20 pounds per cubic foot. We measured the hole diameters with a coordinate measuring machine and analyzed the relationship between the drill-hole diameters and the densities of the simulated bones. We then compared the screw pull-out strength between the two 3.5-diameter drill bits.

Results

In all cases, the diameters of the drill holes were larger than those of the drill bits. The relationship between the drill-hole diameters and the bone densities was a negative linear correlation. Enlarging the hole diameter decreased the screw pull-out strength.

Conclusions

For cannulated drill bits of 3.5, 4.2 and 4.4 mm diameter, the diameter of the drill hole in cancellous bone obtained by the manual drilling technique tends to be larger in low-density (e.g., osteoporotic) compared to high-density (e.g., healthy) bone.