Sex differences for clinical correlates of substantia nigra neuron loss in people with Lewy body pathology

Abstract

Lewy body dementia (LBD) phenotype is associated with the presence and degree of Lewy body, Alzheimer’s pathologies, and substantia nigra neuron loss. Nigral neuron loss is associated with parkinsonism in LBD, and females with LBD are less likely than males to have parkinsonism. As sex differences were reported for clinical correlates of Lewy body and Alzheimer’s pathologies, we aimed to investigate whether there are also sex differences for correlates of nigral neuron loss. Data were obtained from the National Alzheimer’s Coordinating Center for females (n = 159) and males (n = 263) with brainstem, limbic, and neocortical Lewy body pathology. Sex differences for the nigral neuron loss’ association with Lewy body pathology staging and core clinical LBD features (cognitive fluctuations, visual hallucinations, rapid eye movement sleep behavior disorder, parkinsonism) during follow-up were analyzed with generalized linear models adjusting for age and Alzheimer’s pathology staging. Whether any of the core clinical features at the time of dementia onset can predict underlying nigral neuron loss for females and males were also analyzed with generalized linear models. Compared to males, females died older and had higher levels of Braak tau staging, but had similar levels of Lewy body pathology staging and nigral neuron loss. Females were less likely than males to have a clinical Lewy body disease diagnosis during follow-up. More advanced Lewy body pathology staging was associated with more nigral neuron loss, more so for males than females. More nigral neuron loss was associated with parkinsonism and clinical LBD diagnosis during follow-up, more so for males than females. Across the subgroup with dementia (40 females, 58 males), core LBD features at first visit with dementia were not associated with nigral neuron loss. Nigral neuron loss’ association with Lewy body pathology staging and core LBD features can differ by sex. Compared to males, females with Lewy body pathology have a higher risk of underdiagnosis. There is a need to elucidate the mechanisms underlying sex differences for pathology and clinicopathological correlations to advance diagnostic and therapeutic efforts in LBD. Lewy body dementia (LBD) is the third most common dementia associated with Lewy body pathology, Alzheimer’s pathology, and substantia nigra loss. It is often less recognized in females compared to males, because the typical symptoms are less evident in females. In this study, we investigated whether substantia nigra neuron loss plays a role in the atypical presentation of LBD in females, contributing to the underdiagnosis compared to males. We analyzed data from 159 females and 263 males with pathological Lewy body disease obtained from the National Alzheimer's Coordinating Center. Females tended to be older at the time of death and had more tau buildup, but similar levels of Lewy body pathology and substantia nigra neuron loss compared to males. When we compared males and females of similar age with similar levels of Alzheimer's pathology, we observed that females had less substantia nigra neuron loss at less advanced Lewy body pathology stages. Greater nigral neuron loss was associated with parkinsonism and the typical LBD symptoms in males, but not as strongly in females. The extent of nigral loss could not be predicted based on the clinical features at the time of dementia diagnosis. Thus, the relationship between nigral neuron loss and the LBD symptoms seems to vary by sex. Females with underlying Lewy body disease are more likely to be underdiagnosed compared to males. We need further work to understand why these sex differences exist and how we can better identify and treat LBD.