Estimation, Comparison, and Projection of Multifactor Age–Cohort Affine Mortality Models

Abstract

Affine mortality models, developed in continuous time, are well suited to longevity risk applications including pricing and capital management. A major advantage of this mortality modeling approach is the availability of closed-form cohort survival curves, consistent with the assumed time dynamics of mortality rates. This article makes new contributions to the estimation of multifactor continuous-time affine models including the canonical Blackburn-Sherris, the arbitrage-free Nelson-Siegel (AFNS), and the Cox-Ingersoll-Ross (CIR) mortality models. We discuss and address numerical issues with model estimation. We apply the estimation methods to age–cohort mortality data from five different countries, providing insights into the dynamics of mortality rates and the fitting performance of the models. We show how the use of maximum likelihood with the univariate Kalman filter turns out to be faster and more robust compared to traditional estimation methods that heavily use large matrix multiplication and inversion. We present graphical and numerical goodness-of-fit results and assess model robustness. We project cohort survival curves and assess the out-of-sample performance of the models for the five countries. We confirm previous results by showing that, across these countries, although the CIR mortality model fits the historical mortality data well, particularly at older ages, the canonical and AFNS affine mortality models provide better out-of-sample performance. We also show how these affine mortality models are robust with respect to the set of age–cohort data used for parameter estimation. R code is provided.