#MeToo and Literary Studies: Reading, Writing, and Teaching about Sexual Violence and Rape Culture ed. by Mary K. Holland and Heather Hewett (review)

IF 0.1 4区 文学 0 LANGUAGE & LINGUISTICS
{"title":"#MeToo and Literary Studies: Reading, Writing, and Teaching about Sexual Violence and Rape Culture ed. by Mary K. Holland and Heather Hewett (review)","authors":"","doi":"10.1353/mlr.2023.a907850","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Reviewed by: #MeToo and Literary Studies: Reading, Writing, and Teaching about Sexual Violence and Rape Culture ed. by Mary K. Holland and Heather Hewett Julie Anne Taddeo #MeToo and Literary Studies: Reading, Writing, and Teaching about Sexual Violence and Rape Culture. Ed. by Mary K. Holland and Heather Hewett. London: Bloomsbury Academic. 2021. xiii+ 415 pp. £90 (pbk £24.99). ISBN 978–1–5013–7274–2 (pbk 978–1–5013–7273–5). Twice a year, students on my university campus participate in the Clothesline Project using T-shirts to reveal, perhaps for the first time, their own experiences as [End Page 601] sexual assault survivors. Thousands of students, faculty, and staff walk by, some stopping to read and photograph the shirts, and perhaps recognize themselves in these brief accounts from mostly young women, but also some men, about what happened to them as children and/or young adults. The Clothesline Project was created in 1990 by the Cape Cod Women's Defense Agenda; its website explains that 'during the same time 58,000 soldiers were killed in the Vietnam War, 51,000 U.S. women were killed by the men who claimed to love them' (<https://clotheslineproject.info/about.html> [accessed 20 January 2023]). More than three decades later, it remains an example of what Mary K. Holland and Heather Hewett propose in their Introduction to this edited collection: that we use literature in its varied forms—whether it is a medieval text, digital hashtags, or brief stories on T-shirts—to critique rape culture and act to end it. As Holland and Hewett remind us in their Introduction, #MeToo began in 2006 with Tarana Burke's revelation on MySpace of her own sexual assault, but it took the star power of actors such as Alyssa Milano and Ashley Judd to make the hashtag go viral in 2017, in the aftermath of the arrest of Harvey Weinstein. Since 2017, academic scholarship has responded with special journal issues and monographs that largely re-examine canonical works through the lens of #MeToo. Holland and Hewett's edited collection, however, stands out not only for its intersectional and international approach to texts that span two thousand years—from Ovid to Roxane Gay, from medieval England to postcolonial India—but also for the book's second half, which offers readers pedagogical approaches and practices, with examples of both successful and unsuccessful classroom instruction. In such a brief review, it is difficult to single out any particular chapter among the twenty-eight contributions, but all of them highlight the potential for literary studies to effect change in and beyond the university classroom. Holland and Hewett observe that hashtag activism 'has its roots in over two centuries of activism, advocacy work, and writing about sexual violence' (p. 3). Likewise, hashtag activism invites scholars and students to engage in new interpretations of old texts; one such example is described in Chapter 8, in which twenty-first-century Indian college students, responding to high-profile rape and 'slut-shaming' cases, use Ovid's Philomela to understand how girls and women are still routinely silenced. Second-wave feminism, though often faulted for its lack of intersectionalism, taught us to read literary representations of rape 'literally, not just 'as a trope for something else' (p. 5). Yet even current anti-rape activism, Holland and Hewett rightly contend, has shortcomings, often privileging the experiences and voices of cisgender, white, heterosexual women. In response, this collection covers the relationship between colonialism, slavery, racism, and sexual violence in far-ranging texts, from Harriet Jacobs's Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl and Chinua Achebe's Things Fall Apart, to Black street lit. Furthermore, several chapters discuss contemporary texts by and/or about sexual violence against trans and non-binary people of colour and Indigenous women. While most of the collection focuses on literature about the more pervasive experience of male violence [End Page 602] against women, stories of male rape (perpetrated by both men and women) are also under analysis in this volume. Contributor Kasey Jones-Matrona summarizes one of the collection's unifying themes, that 'literature and all forms of storytelling, including oral traditions, are all...","PeriodicalId":45399,"journal":{"name":"MODERN LANGUAGE REVIEW","volume":"23 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.1000,"publicationDate":"2023-10-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"2","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"MODERN LANGUAGE REVIEW","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1353/mlr.2023.a907850","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"文学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"LANGUAGE & LINGUISTICS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 2

Abstract

Reviewed by: #MeToo and Literary Studies: Reading, Writing, and Teaching about Sexual Violence and Rape Culture ed. by Mary K. Holland and Heather Hewett Julie Anne Taddeo #MeToo and Literary Studies: Reading, Writing, and Teaching about Sexual Violence and Rape Culture. Ed. by Mary K. Holland and Heather Hewett. London: Bloomsbury Academic. 2021. xiii+ 415 pp. £90 (pbk £24.99). ISBN 978–1–5013–7274–2 (pbk 978–1–5013–7273–5). Twice a year, students on my university campus participate in the Clothesline Project using T-shirts to reveal, perhaps for the first time, their own experiences as [End Page 601] sexual assault survivors. Thousands of students, faculty, and staff walk by, some stopping to read and photograph the shirts, and perhaps recognize themselves in these brief accounts from mostly young women, but also some men, about what happened to them as children and/or young adults. The Clothesline Project was created in 1990 by the Cape Cod Women's Defense Agenda; its website explains that 'during the same time 58,000 soldiers were killed in the Vietnam War, 51,000 U.S. women were killed by the men who claimed to love them' ( [accessed 20 January 2023]). More than three decades later, it remains an example of what Mary K. Holland and Heather Hewett propose in their Introduction to this edited collection: that we use literature in its varied forms—whether it is a medieval text, digital hashtags, or brief stories on T-shirts—to critique rape culture and act to end it. As Holland and Hewett remind us in their Introduction, #MeToo began in 2006 with Tarana Burke's revelation on MySpace of her own sexual assault, but it took the star power of actors such as Alyssa Milano and Ashley Judd to make the hashtag go viral in 2017, in the aftermath of the arrest of Harvey Weinstein. Since 2017, academic scholarship has responded with special journal issues and monographs that largely re-examine canonical works through the lens of #MeToo. Holland and Hewett's edited collection, however, stands out not only for its intersectional and international approach to texts that span two thousand years—from Ovid to Roxane Gay, from medieval England to postcolonial India—but also for the book's second half, which offers readers pedagogical approaches and practices, with examples of both successful and unsuccessful classroom instruction. In such a brief review, it is difficult to single out any particular chapter among the twenty-eight contributions, but all of them highlight the potential for literary studies to effect change in and beyond the university classroom. Holland and Hewett observe that hashtag activism 'has its roots in over two centuries of activism, advocacy work, and writing about sexual violence' (p. 3). Likewise, hashtag activism invites scholars and students to engage in new interpretations of old texts; one such example is described in Chapter 8, in which twenty-first-century Indian college students, responding to high-profile rape and 'slut-shaming' cases, use Ovid's Philomela to understand how girls and women are still routinely silenced. Second-wave feminism, though often faulted for its lack of intersectionalism, taught us to read literary representations of rape 'literally, not just 'as a trope for something else' (p. 5). Yet even current anti-rape activism, Holland and Hewett rightly contend, has shortcomings, often privileging the experiences and voices of cisgender, white, heterosexual women. In response, this collection covers the relationship between colonialism, slavery, racism, and sexual violence in far-ranging texts, from Harriet Jacobs's Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl and Chinua Achebe's Things Fall Apart, to Black street lit. Furthermore, several chapters discuss contemporary texts by and/or about sexual violence against trans and non-binary people of colour and Indigenous women. While most of the collection focuses on literature about the more pervasive experience of male violence [End Page 602] against women, stories of male rape (perpetrated by both men and women) are also under analysis in this volume. Contributor Kasey Jones-Matrona summarizes one of the collection's unifying themes, that 'literature and all forms of storytelling, including oral traditions, are all...
#MeToo与文学研究:关于性暴力和强奸文化的阅读、写作和教学,玛丽·k·霍兰德、希瑟·休伊特主编(书评)
作者:玛丽·k·霍兰德和希瑟·休伊特主编:《#MeToo与文学研究:关于性暴力和强奸文化的阅读、写作和教学》玛丽·k·霍兰德和希瑟·休伊特主编。伦敦:布鲁姆斯伯里学术出版社,2021。13 + 415页,90英镑(每磅24.99英镑)。ISBN 978-1-5013-7274-2 (pbk 978-1-5013-7273-5)。我所在的大学校园里,学生们每年都会用t恤参加“晾衣绳计划”(Clothesline Project),也许这是他们第一次公开自己作为性侵幸存者的经历。成千上万的学生、教师和工作人员走过,一些人停下来阅读和拍摄这些衬衫,也许在这些简短的描述中认出了自己,这些描述大多是年轻女性,也有一些男性,讲述了他们小时候和/或年轻时发生的事情。晾衣绳项目是由科德角妇女保护议程于1990年创建的;其网站解释说,“在同一时期,58,000名士兵在越南战争中丧生,51,000名美国妇女被声称爱她们的男人杀害”。三十多年后,它仍然是玛丽·k·霍兰德和希瑟·休伊特在这本编辑集的导言中提出的一个例子:我们利用各种形式的文学——无论是中世纪的文本、数字标签,还是t恤上的短篇故事——来批评强奸文化,并采取行动结束它。正如霍兰德和休伊特在他们的介绍中提醒我们的那样,#MeToo始于2006年塔拉娜·伯克在MySpace上披露自己的性侵犯,但直到2017年,在哈维·韦恩斯坦被捕之后,艾丽莎·米兰诺和阿什利·贾德等演员的明星效应,才使这个标签在网上走红。自2017年以来,学术学者以特刊和专著作为回应,这些专著在很大程度上通过#MeToo的视角重新审视了经典作品。然而,霍兰德和休伊特的编辑合集的突出之处不仅在于它对跨越两千年的文本的交叉和国际化的研究方法——从奥维德到罗克森·盖伊,从中世纪的英格兰到后殖民时期的印度——而且还在于书的后半部分,它为读者提供了教学方法和实践,并提供了成功和不成功的课堂教学的例子。在这样一个简短的回顾中,很难从28个贡献中挑出任何一个特定的章节,但它们都强调了文学研究在大学课堂内外影响变革的潜力。霍兰和休伊特观察到,标签行动主义“源于两个多世纪以来关于性暴力的行动主义、倡导工作和写作”(第3页)。同样,标签行动主义邀请学者和学生对旧文本进行新的解释;第8章描述了一个这样的例子,21世纪的印度大学生,在回应备受瞩目的强奸和“荡妇羞辱”案件时,用奥维德的菲罗梅拉来理解女孩和女人是如何经常保持沉默的。第二波女权主义,虽然经常因为缺乏交叉主义而受到指责,但教会我们“从字面上理解”强奸的文学表现,而不仅仅是“作为其他事物的隐喻”(第5页)。然而,霍兰和休伊特正确地认为,即使是当前的反强奸行动主义,也有缺点,经常优先考虑顺性别、白人、异性恋女性的经历和声音。作为回应,本作品集涵盖了广泛文本中殖民主义、奴隶制、种族主义和性暴力之间的关系,从哈里特·雅各布斯的《一个奴隶女孩的生活》和奇努亚·阿奇贝的《分崩离析》,到黑人街头照明。此外,有几个章节讨论了当代文本中针对跨性别、非二元人种和土著妇女的性暴力。虽然这本书的大部分内容都集中在关于男性对女性施暴的普遍经历的文学作品上,但男性强奸(男性和女性犯下的)的故事也在本卷中进行了分析。撰稿人凯西·琼斯-马特罗纳总结了这本书的一个统一主题,那就是“文学和所有形式的讲故事,包括口头传统,都是……
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
求助全文
约1分钟内获得全文 求助全文
来源期刊
CiteScore
0.10
自引率
0.00%
发文量
157
期刊介绍: With an unbroken publication record since 1905, its 1248 pages are divided between articles, predominantly on medieval and modern literature, in the languages of continental Europe, together with English (including the United States and the Commonwealth), Francophone Africa and Canada, and Latin America. In addition, MLR reviews over five hundred books each year The MLR Supplement The Modern Language Review was founded in 1905 and has included well over 3,000 articles and some 20,000 book reviews. This supplement to Volume 100 is published by the Modern Humanities Research Association in celebration of the centenary of its flagship journal.
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信