{"title":"Çalışma Hikayesi Olan Suriyeli Çocukların Eğitim Sorunları Üzerine Nitel Bir Araştırma","authors":"Enver Mengü, Ö. Yaman","doi":"10.7827/turkishstudies.52265","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Children who are defenceles side of the war, are becoming disadvantageous with their process of the forced emigration and also the period of the studies. Emigrant children’s education issue has critical importance because of finishing the disadvantages circumstance of studies and having adaptation with society which they live in. Thus, this vulnerable group’s process of the education has new difficulties which they have to struggle against them beside the difficulties which they had until reaching. At this point, some non-governmental organisations have significant and unique studies on the purpose of including Syrian children in the education life and standing by them against the difficulties of education process. In this scope of research, association which choosed with purposive sampling had focus group discussion with 4 students and in-depth interview with 17 students which are participating education life instead of working life. This research was found ethically appropriate according to the decision of the social and human sciences research and publication ethics committee, dated 07.12.2021 and numbered 2021/67. Thereafter, in this qualitative research which is conducted with descriptive approach proved the difficulties and struggles which Syrian children’s had initially passing from working life to education life and after orientating the education system. Accordingly, it is possible to list the problems in their working life that working hours, working conditions and the hurtful attitudes in working environment. In addition, the problems in Syrian children’s education life that the difficulties of the lessons, the hurtful attitudes of the the teachers and the hate speech directed by other students. Structured Abstract: After the civil war in Syria in 2011, 10 years have passed and the number of Syrians who took as refugee in Turkey has exceeded 3 million. Due to its diameter, in this largest migration wave encountered in Turkey's migration history (Erdoğan, 2015: 342), the ongoing crisis environment in Syria still proceed the migration process. With the prolongation of this process, an intersectional disadvantage is emerged. Because Syrian children, who are already in a disadvantageous position with the migration process due to the war, experience a second disadvantage with the education process which they stay away from. Syrian children who have already interrupted their education due to the conditions in their home country before seeking asylum, were exposed to the continuation of discontinuity in their education for a Öğr. Gör., İstanbul Medeniyet Üniversitesi, Sağlık Bilimleri Fakültesi, Sosyal Hizmet Bölümü Lecturer, İstanbul Medeniyet University, Faculty of Health Sciences, Social Work Department 0000-0001-6871-688X envermengu@gmail.com ** Doç. Dr., İstanbul Üniversitesi-Cerrahpaşa, Sağlık Bilimleri Fakültesi, Sosyal Hizmet Bölümü Lecturer, İstanbul University-Cerrahpaşa, Faculty of Health Sciences, Social Work Department 0000-0001-9989-8575 omermirac@gmail.com 2060 Enver Mengü Ömer Miraç Yaman Turkish Studies Social, 16(6) while due to the demand for both a residence permit document and a document stating their previous education status in Turkey. Although the Temporary Protection Regulation has succeeded in removing bureaucratic obstacles in many dimensions regarding the education of Syrian children, financial difficulties remain as the limiting factor in the education issue. Although, Geçici Koruma Yönetmeliği (the Temporary Protection Regulation) has succeeded in removing bureaucratic obstacles in many points of views regarding the education of Syrian children, financial difficulties remain as the limiting factor for education continuity. As a matter of fact, educational materials and transportation costs can increase the total cost of the school and it puts Syrian families even more difficult economically. For this reason, Syrian families force their children either to work (Çiçekli, 2009: 8) or to marry (Culbertson & Constant, 2015: 19) due to financial inadequacy and economic pressures. The deprivation which is experienced by Syrian children in education is primarily a matter of fundamental rights. Because, in accordance with the principles that guide policies on immigrant children on the basis of international law, the child has the best benefit (Atasü-Topçuoğlu, 2012: 71-72). Secondly, the deprivation that Syrian children are exposed to in terms of education makes them more prone to harmful groups and habits (Aras & Yasun, 2016: 2). For this reason, the education campaign that started with Geçici Eğitim Merkezleri (the Temporary Education Centers) has gained importance and prevalence in the last period. Furthermore, while it is relatively important to overcome the obstacles to the education of Syrian children and their access to education, mostly, they are not sufficient. As a matter of fact, Syrian children encounter new problems during the education process. Syrian children which, encounter with a different language structure (İ.H.İ.Ö., 2015: 18), an unfamiliar curriculum accompanied by a foreign teacher (Emin, 2016: 21-22), and generally in overcrowded classrooms (Kirişçi, 2014: 26), enter a chaotic educational process that requires an effort to follow. In this regard, education centers, which are produced by nongovernmental organizations and provide reinforcement lessons for Syrian children, have also come to the fore in time, providing them with certain skills along with religious and language education (Culbertson & Constant, 2015: 20). Within the scope of this research, Syrian children who were brought into education from working life through Yeryüzü Çocukları Derneği (the Earth Children's Association) were discussed. In this context, the difficulties that Syrian migrant children face in their working life in Turkey, the difficulties they face in their education life after being included in the education system in Turkey, and the representatives of Yeryüzü Çocukları Derneği (the Earth Children's Association) in particular and a non-governmental organization in general will be presented. With the protracted migration process, integration policies have started to become more significant in Turkey. The primary target group of the integration policies is the Syrian children. Because children stand out compared to adults because of their learning skills and adaptability. The critical role of children in adaptation gives its first appearance for the education life. Educational problems of Syrian children will have a direct impact for firstly on school dropout and later on crime rates. For this reason, it is important to make the problems, which they encounter, visible and to highlight examples of solutions. This research is important because of this aspect. This research is found ethically appropriate according to the decision of the social and human sciences research and publication ethics committee, dated 07.12.2021 and numbered 2021/67. In this study, which was conducted with a total of 17 Syrian children who were brought into education life from working life, qualitative research was preferred as it would provide a descriptive variation by providing the opportunity to see the problems experienced by the children from their own perspective and to convey their experiences in their own language. In the scope of qualitative research, purposive sampling method, which is considered as non-probability sampling method, was preferred. In addition to the observation information obtained by being involved in the education process, in-depth interviews and focus group techniques will be used to reveal the work stories of Syrian children, their ideas about work and education, the problems they encounter in education and the mechanisms they have developed for the problems they encounter. According to the results, first of all, the majority of children complained about the length of the working period. Secondly, the majority of the children stated that they were very hurt because of the treatment towards them at work. Other answers given by the children on the difficulties of working life were given as “standing”, “carrying heavy things” and “waking up (early) in the morning”. Çalışma Hikayesi Olan Suriyeli Çocukların Eğitim Sorunları Üzerine Nitel Bir Araştırma 2061 www.turkishstudies.net/social It is possible to take the difficulties faced by Syrian children in education through three dimensions: lessons, teachers and students. The courses that students say they often have difficulties as Turkish, Literature, Mathematics and English. Participating children claim that as a result of the interviews, teachers deliberately gave them low performance grades in their homework. The most interesting information from the interviews is about the student point of view of the difficulties they experience in education. Because most Syrian students state that their schoolmates are exposed to a lot of hate speech.","PeriodicalId":257041,"journal":{"name":"Turkish Studies-Social Sciences","volume":"62 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"1900-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Turkish Studies-Social Sciences","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.7827/turkishstudies.52265","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Children who are defenceles side of the war, are becoming disadvantageous with their process of the forced emigration and also the period of the studies. Emigrant children’s education issue has critical importance because of finishing the disadvantages circumstance of studies and having adaptation with society which they live in. Thus, this vulnerable group’s process of the education has new difficulties which they have to struggle against them beside the difficulties which they had until reaching. At this point, some non-governmental organisations have significant and unique studies on the purpose of including Syrian children in the education life and standing by them against the difficulties of education process. In this scope of research, association which choosed with purposive sampling had focus group discussion with 4 students and in-depth interview with 17 students which are participating education life instead of working life. This research was found ethically appropriate according to the decision of the social and human sciences research and publication ethics committee, dated 07.12.2021 and numbered 2021/67. Thereafter, in this qualitative research which is conducted with descriptive approach proved the difficulties and struggles which Syrian children’s had initially passing from working life to education life and after orientating the education system. Accordingly, it is possible to list the problems in their working life that working hours, working conditions and the hurtful attitudes in working environment. In addition, the problems in Syrian children’s education life that the difficulties of the lessons, the hurtful attitudes of the the teachers and the hate speech directed by other students. Structured Abstract: After the civil war in Syria in 2011, 10 years have passed and the number of Syrians who took as refugee in Turkey has exceeded 3 million. Due to its diameter, in this largest migration wave encountered in Turkey's migration history (Erdoğan, 2015: 342), the ongoing crisis environment in Syria still proceed the migration process. With the prolongation of this process, an intersectional disadvantage is emerged. Because Syrian children, who are already in a disadvantageous position with the migration process due to the war, experience a second disadvantage with the education process which they stay away from. Syrian children who have already interrupted their education due to the conditions in their home country before seeking asylum, were exposed to the continuation of discontinuity in their education for a Öğr. Gör., İstanbul Medeniyet Üniversitesi, Sağlık Bilimleri Fakültesi, Sosyal Hizmet Bölümü Lecturer, İstanbul Medeniyet University, Faculty of Health Sciences, Social Work Department 0000-0001-6871-688X envermengu@gmail.com ** Doç. Dr., İstanbul Üniversitesi-Cerrahpaşa, Sağlık Bilimleri Fakültesi, Sosyal Hizmet Bölümü Lecturer, İstanbul University-Cerrahpaşa, Faculty of Health Sciences, Social Work Department 0000-0001-9989-8575 omermirac@gmail.com 2060 Enver Mengü Ömer Miraç Yaman Turkish Studies Social, 16(6) while due to the demand for both a residence permit document and a document stating their previous education status in Turkey. Although the Temporary Protection Regulation has succeeded in removing bureaucratic obstacles in many dimensions regarding the education of Syrian children, financial difficulties remain as the limiting factor in the education issue. Although, Geçici Koruma Yönetmeliği (the Temporary Protection Regulation) has succeeded in removing bureaucratic obstacles in many points of views regarding the education of Syrian children, financial difficulties remain as the limiting factor for education continuity. As a matter of fact, educational materials and transportation costs can increase the total cost of the school and it puts Syrian families even more difficult economically. For this reason, Syrian families force their children either to work (Çiçekli, 2009: 8) or to marry (Culbertson & Constant, 2015: 19) due to financial inadequacy and economic pressures. The deprivation which is experienced by Syrian children in education is primarily a matter of fundamental rights. Because, in accordance with the principles that guide policies on immigrant children on the basis of international law, the child has the best benefit (Atasü-Topçuoğlu, 2012: 71-72). Secondly, the deprivation that Syrian children are exposed to in terms of education makes them more prone to harmful groups and habits (Aras & Yasun, 2016: 2). For this reason, the education campaign that started with Geçici Eğitim Merkezleri (the Temporary Education Centers) has gained importance and prevalence in the last period. Furthermore, while it is relatively important to overcome the obstacles to the education of Syrian children and their access to education, mostly, they are not sufficient. As a matter of fact, Syrian children encounter new problems during the education process. Syrian children which, encounter with a different language structure (İ.H.İ.Ö., 2015: 18), an unfamiliar curriculum accompanied by a foreign teacher (Emin, 2016: 21-22), and generally in overcrowded classrooms (Kirişçi, 2014: 26), enter a chaotic educational process that requires an effort to follow. In this regard, education centers, which are produced by nongovernmental organizations and provide reinforcement lessons for Syrian children, have also come to the fore in time, providing them with certain skills along with religious and language education (Culbertson & Constant, 2015: 20). Within the scope of this research, Syrian children who were brought into education from working life through Yeryüzü Çocukları Derneği (the Earth Children's Association) were discussed. In this context, the difficulties that Syrian migrant children face in their working life in Turkey, the difficulties they face in their education life after being included in the education system in Turkey, and the representatives of Yeryüzü Çocukları Derneği (the Earth Children's Association) in particular and a non-governmental organization in general will be presented. With the protracted migration process, integration policies have started to become more significant in Turkey. The primary target group of the integration policies is the Syrian children. Because children stand out compared to adults because of their learning skills and adaptability. The critical role of children in adaptation gives its first appearance for the education life. Educational problems of Syrian children will have a direct impact for firstly on school dropout and later on crime rates. For this reason, it is important to make the problems, which they encounter, visible and to highlight examples of solutions. This research is important because of this aspect. This research is found ethically appropriate according to the decision of the social and human sciences research and publication ethics committee, dated 07.12.2021 and numbered 2021/67. In this study, which was conducted with a total of 17 Syrian children who were brought into education life from working life, qualitative research was preferred as it would provide a descriptive variation by providing the opportunity to see the problems experienced by the children from their own perspective and to convey their experiences in their own language. In the scope of qualitative research, purposive sampling method, which is considered as non-probability sampling method, was preferred. In addition to the observation information obtained by being involved in the education process, in-depth interviews and focus group techniques will be used to reveal the work stories of Syrian children, their ideas about work and education, the problems they encounter in education and the mechanisms they have developed for the problems they encounter. According to the results, first of all, the majority of children complained about the length of the working period. Secondly, the majority of the children stated that they were very hurt because of the treatment towards them at work. Other answers given by the children on the difficulties of working life were given as “standing”, “carrying heavy things” and “waking up (early) in the morning”. Çalışma Hikayesi Olan Suriyeli Çocukların Eğitim Sorunları Üzerine Nitel Bir Araştırma 2061 www.turkishstudies.net/social It is possible to take the difficulties faced by Syrian children in education through three dimensions: lessons, teachers and students. The courses that students say they often have difficulties as Turkish, Literature, Mathematics and English. Participating children claim that as a result of the interviews, teachers deliberately gave them low performance grades in their homework. The most interesting information from the interviews is about the student point of view of the difficulties they experience in education. Because most Syrian students state that their schoolmates are exposed to a lot of hate speech.
作为战争一方的被告方的儿童,随着他们被迫移民的过程和学习的时间,正变得越来越不利。外来务工人员子女的教育问题因其摆脱不利的学习环境,适应所处的社会而显得尤为重要。因此,这一弱势群体的教育过程中除了遇到的困难之外,还有新的困难要与之抗争。在这一点上,一些非政府组织对将叙利亚儿童纳入教育生活的目的进行了重要而独特的研究,并与他们一起应对教育过程中的困难。在这个研究范围内,协会选择了有目的的抽样,对4名学生进行了焦点小组讨论,对17名参与教育生活而不是工作生活的学生进行了深度访谈。根据社会和人文科学研究和出版伦理委员会的决定,本研究在伦理上是合适的,该决定日期为2021年12月7日,编号为2021/67。此后,在这项定性研究中,用描述的方法证明了叙利亚儿童最初从工作生活过渡到教育生活以及在教育系统定位之后所遇到的困难和斗争。因此,有可能列出他们工作生活中的问题,工作时间,工作条件和工作环境中的有害态度。此外,叙利亚儿童教育生活中的问题包括课程的困难、教师的伤害态度和其他学生的仇恨言论。摘要:2011年叙利亚内战爆发后,10年过去了,土耳其接纳的叙利亚难民人数已超过300万。由于它的直径,在土耳其移民史上遇到的最大的移民浪潮中(Erdoğan, 2015: 342),叙利亚持续的危机环境仍然在进行移民过程。随着这一过程的延长,一个交叉的缺点出现了。因为叙利亚儿童,由于战争已经在移民过程中处于不利地位,在他们远离的教育过程中经历了第二个不利地位。在寻求庇护之前,由于本国的条件已经中断了教育的叙利亚儿童,将继续面临教育中断的情况,时间长达Öğr。气油比。, İstanbul mediyet Üniversitesi, Sağlık Bilimleri fak<e:1> ltesi, Sosyal Hizmet Bölümü讲师,İstanbul mediyet大学健康科学学院,社会工作系0000-0001-6871-688X envermengu@gmail.com ** Doç。博士,İstanbul Üniversitesi-Cerrahpaşa, Sağlık Bilimleri fak<e:1> ltesi, Sosyal Hizmet Bölümü讲师,İstanbul cerrahpa<e:1>大学,健康科学学院,社会工作系0000-0001-9989-8575 omermirac@gmail.com 2060 Enver Mengü Ömer Miraç Yaman土耳其社会研究,16(6),同时由于需要居留许可文件和说明他们以前在土耳其的教育状况的文件。虽然《临时保护条例》在许多方面成功地消除了有关叙利亚儿童教育的官僚障碍,但财政困难仍然是教育问题的限制因素。虽然geici Koruma Yönetmeliği(临时保护条例)成功地消除了关于叙利亚儿童教育的许多方面的官僚障碍,但财政困难仍然是教育连续性的限制因素。事实上,教育材料和交通费用会增加学校的总成本,使叙利亚家庭在经济上更加困难。出于这个原因,叙利亚家庭迫使他们的孩子要么工作(Çiçekli, 2009: 8),要么结婚(Culbertson & Constant, 2015: 19),原因是经济上的不足和经济压力。叙利亚儿童所经历的教育剥夺主要是一个基本权利问题。因为,根据国际法指导移民儿童政策的原则,儿童享有最大利益(Atasü-Topçuoğlu, 2012: 71-72)。其次,叙利亚儿童在教育方面的剥夺使他们更容易受到有害群体和习惯的影响(Aras & Yasun, 2016: 2)。因此,从geici Eğitim Merkezleri(临时教育中心)开始的教育运动在上一时期变得越来越重要和流行。此外,虽然克服阻碍叙利亚儿童接受教育和获得教育的障碍相对重要,但大多数情况下,这些障碍是不够的。事实上,叙利亚儿童在接受教育的过程中也遇到了新的问题。 遇到不同语言结构的叙利亚儿童(İ.H.İ.Ö)。(Emin, 2016: 21-22),通常在拥挤的教室(kirii, 2014: 26),进入一个混乱的教育过程,需要努力遵循。在这方面,由非政府组织建立并为叙利亚儿童提供强化课程的教育中心也及时出现,为他们提供一定的技能以及宗教和语言教育(Culbertson & Constant, 2015: 20)。在本研究的范围内,讨论了通过Yeryüzü Çocukları Derneği(地球儿童协会)从工作生活中接受教育的叙利亚儿童。在这方面,将介绍叙利亚移徙儿童在土耳其的工作生活中遇到的困难,他们被纳入土耳其教育系统后在教育生活中遇到的困难,特别是Yeryüzü Çocukları Derneği(地球儿童协会)的代表和一般非政府组织的代表。随着移民进程的延长,土耳其的融合政策开始变得更加重要。融入政策的主要目标群体是叙利亚儿童。因为与成年人相比,孩子的学习能力和适应能力更强。儿童在教育生活中的适应作用初露端面。叙利亚儿童的教育问题将首先直接影响辍学,然后影响犯罪率。出于这个原因,重要的是要使他们遇到的问题可见,并强调解决方案的例子。这方面的研究很重要。根据社会和人文科学研究和出版伦理委员会的决定,本研究在伦理上是合适的,该决定日期为2021年12月7日,编号为2021/67。在这项研究中,共有17名叙利亚儿童从工作生活中进入教育生活,质性研究是首选,因为它可以提供一种描述性的变化,提供机会从他们自己的角度看到孩子们所经历的问题,并用他们自己的语言传达他们的经验。在定性研究的范围内,有目的的抽样方法被认为是一种非概率抽样方法。除了通过参与教育过程获得的观察信息外,还将使用深度访谈和焦点小组技术来揭示叙利亚儿童的工作故事,他们对工作和教育的看法,他们在教育中遇到的问题以及他们为遇到的问题制定的机制。根据调查结果,首先,大多数孩子抱怨工作时间过长。其次,大多数儿童表示,由于在工作中受到的待遇,他们受到了很大的伤害。关于工作生活的困难,孩子们给出的其他答案包括“站立”、“搬运重物”和“早上(早起)”。Çalışma Hikayesi Olan Suriyeli Çocukların Eğitim sorunlaryi Üzerine Nitel Bir Araştırma 2061 www.turkishstudies.net/social我们可以从课程、教师和学生这三个方面来分析叙利亚儿童在教育方面面临的困难。学生们说他们经常有困难的课程有土耳其语、文学、数学和英语。参与调查的孩子们声称,由于采访的结果,老师故意给他们的家庭作业打低分。采访中最有趣的信息是关于学生对他们在教育中遇到的困难的看法。因为大多数叙利亚学生表示,他们的同学接触到很多仇恨言论。 遇到不同语言结构的叙利亚儿童(İ.H.İ.Ö)。(Emin, 2016: 21-22),通常在拥挤的教室(kirii, 2014: 26),进入一个混乱的教育过程,需要努力遵循。在这方面,由非政府组织建立并为叙利亚儿童提供强化课程的教育中心也及时出现,为他们提供一定的技能以及宗教和语言教育(Culbertson & Constant, 2015: 20)。在本研究的范围内,讨论了通过Yeryüzü Çocukları Derneği(地球儿童协会)从工作生活中接受教育的叙利亚儿童。在这方面,将介绍叙利亚移徙儿童在土耳其的工作生活中遇到的困难,他们被纳入土耳其教育系统后在教育生活中遇到的困难,特别是Yeryüzü Çocukları Derneği(地球儿童协会)的代表和一般非政府组织的代表。随着移民进程的延长,土耳其的融合政策开始变得更加重要。融入政策的主要目标群体是叙利亚儿童。因为与成年人相比,孩子的学习能力和适应能力更强。儿童在教育生活中的适应作用初露端面。叙利亚儿童的教育问题将首先直接影响辍学,然后影响犯罪率。出于这个原因,重要的是要使他们遇到的问题可见,并强调解决方案的例子。这方面的研究很重要。根据社会和人文科学研究和出版伦理委员会的决定,本研究在伦理上是合适的,该决定日期为2021年12月7日,编号为2021/67。在这项研究中,共有17名叙利亚儿童从工作生活中进入教育生活,质性研究是首选,因为它可以提供一种描述性的变化,提供机会从他们自己的角度看到孩子们所经历的问题,并用他们自己的语言传达他们的经验。在定性研究的范围内,有目的的抽样方法被认为是一种非概率抽样方法。除了通过参与教育过程获得的观察信息外,还将使用深度访谈和焦点小组技术来揭示叙利亚儿童的工作故事,他们对工作和教育的看法,他们在教育中遇到的问题以及他们为遇到的问题制定的机制。根据调查结果,首先,大多数孩子抱怨工作时间过长。其次,大多数儿童表示,由于在工作中受到的待遇,他们受到了很大的伤害。关于工作生活的困难,孩子们给出的其他答案包括“站立”、“搬运重物”和“早上(早起)”。Çalışma Hikayesi Olan Suriyeli Çocukların Eğitim sorunlaryi Üzerine Nitel Bir Araştırma 2061 www.turkishstudies.net/social我们可以从课程、教师和学生这三个方面来分析叙利亚儿童在教育方面面临的困难。学生们说他们经常有困难的课程有土耳其语、文学、数学和英语。参与调查的孩子们声称,由于采访的结果,老师故意给他们的家庭作业打低分。采访中最有趣的信息是关于学生对他们在教育中遇到的困难的看法。因为大多数叙利亚学生表示,他们的同学接触到很多仇恨言论。