Comparing a Scalable SDN Simulation Framework Built on ns-3 and DCE with Existing SDN Simulators and Emulators

Abstract

As software-defined networking (SDN) grows beyond its original aim to simply separate the control and data network planes, it becomes useful both financially and analytically to provide adequate mechanisms for simulating this new paradigm. A number of simulation/emulation tools for modeling SDN, such as Mininet, are already available. A new, novel framework for providing SDN simulation has been provided in this work using the network simulator ns-3. The ns-3 module Direct Code Execution (DCE) allows real-world network applications to be run within a simulated network topology. This work employs DCE for running the SDN controller library POX and its applications on nodes in a simulated network topology. In this way, real-world controller applications can be completely portable between simulation and actual deployment. This work also describes a user-defined ns-3 application mimicking an SDN switch supporting OpenFlow 1.0 that can interact with real-world controllers. To evaluate its performance, this ns-3 DCE SDN framework is compared against Mininet as well as some other readily available SDN simulation/emulation tools. Metrics such as realtime performance, memory usage, and reliability in terms of packet loss are analyzed across the multiple simulation/emulation tools to gauge how they compare.