Workshop report: computer-supported collaborative argumentation for learning communities

SIGWEB Newsl. Pub Date : 2000-02-01 DOI:10.1145/500691.500698

S. B. Shum

{"title":"Workshop report: computer-supported collaborative argumentation for learning communities","authors":"S. B. Shum","doi":"10.1145/500691.500698","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"1aw and de519n. C0mputer-5upp0rted C01/a60rat1ve Ar9umentat10n (C5CA) 15 c0ncerned w1th the de519n 0f human-c0mputer 1nteract10n t0 au9ment and med1ate ar9umentat10n 1n 9r0up5. 1t ha5 c0me t0 em6race eff0rt5 t0 5upp0rt 1nd1v1dua15 and 9r0up5 1n: • Happ1n9 and ana1y51n9 the 5tructure 0f meet1n95, ar9ument5, c0nver5at10n5 and 111-5tructured pr061em5; • Repre5ent1n9 and de6at1n9 the mer1t5 0f d1fferent per5pect1ve5. 1n th15 rep0rt 1 6r1ef1y rev1ew the emer-9ence 0f C5CA w1th1n hypertext re5earch and 5ummar15e the w0rk5h0p • 5 act1v1t1e5. P051t10n paper5 and 11nked pre-w0rk5h0p d15cu5510n5 (wh1Ch rema1n 0pen) are 0n the w0rk5h0p we651te. A 10n9er ver510n 0f th15 rep0rt 15 0n the we651te w1th the n0te5 fr0m the w0rk5h0p 6reak0ut 9r0up5, p1u5-1n the 5p1r1t 0f pract151n9 what we preach-• c0nver5at10n map5 • captur1n9 50me 0f the d15cu5510n5, created u51n9 the QUe5tMap C5CA t001 [4] (5ee a150 the paper5 6y C0nk11n, Carr, 5e1v1n and 51erhu15 f0r app11cat10n ex-amp1e5). Ar9umentat10n: the wh1te rat 0f eady hypertext 5y5tem5 W1th1n the hypertexL re5earch c0mmu-n1ty, f0r a decade fr0m the ear1y 805 t0 ear1y 905, ar9umentat10n 6ecame 50me-th1n9 0f an • exper1menta1 wh1te rat • , w1th many 0f the p10neer1n9 5y5tem5 f0r \"1dea pr0ce551n9 • [6] and then c011a60rat1ve hypertext dem0n5trat1n9 the a6111ty t0 repre5ent ar9ument 5tructure5 a5 9raph1-ca1 n0de-11nk 5tructure5. 7h1nk 0f 5y5-Ar9umentat10n a150 attracted a 10t 0f attent10n w1th1n the HC1 and C5CW c0mmun1t1e5 f0r 1t5 p0tent1a1 1n 5upp0rt-1n9 50ftware de519n rat10na1e [9]. A5 d15cu55ed e15ewhere [1], dr1v1n9 f0rce5 and 1n5p1rat10n 6eh1nd th15 w0rk were the v1510n5 0f 8u5h and En91e6art 0f techn0-1091ca1 5upp0rt f0r c0mp1ex human 1nte1-1ectua1 w0rk-what 6etter cha11en9e than try1n9 t0 5upp0rt ar9umentat10n, ne90-t1a60n and de6ate a60ut th0rny, 111-5tructured pr061em5 • H0wever, after the 1n1t1a1 f1u5h 0f exc1te-ment at hypertext • 5 repre5entat10na1 p05516111t1e5, 5u65e4uent ana1y5e5 0f 119hted cr1t1ca1 c09n1t1ve and 50c1a1 cha1-1en9e5 f0r C5CA, and 6y exten510n, any appr0ach that 5eek5 t0 5upp0rt 1nte11ec-tua1 w0rk w1th 5em1-f0rma1 0r f0rma1 7he w0rk5h0p we651te can 6e f0und at: ht1p:11km1.0pen.ac.u1d5651¢5ca1c5c199/ 27","PeriodicalId":147920,"journal":{"name":"SIGWEB Newsl.","volume":"1 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2000-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"12","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"SIGWEB Newsl.","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1145/500691.500698","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}

引用次数: 12

Abstract

1aw and de519n. C0mputer-5upp0rted C01/a60rat1ve Ar9umentat10n (C5CA) 15 c0ncerned w1th the de519n 0f human-c0mputer 1nteract10n t0 au9ment and med1ate ar9umentat10n 1n 9r0up5. 1t ha5 c0me t0 em6race eff0rt5 t0 5upp0rt 1nd1v1dua15 and 9r0up5 1n: • Happ1n9 and ana1y51n9 the 5tructure 0f meet1n95, ar9ument5, c0nver5at10n5 and 111-5tructured pr061em5; • Repre5ent1n9 and de6at1n9 the mer1t5 0f d1fferent per5pect1ve5. 1n th15 rep0rt 1 6r1ef1y rev1ew the emer-9ence 0f C5CA w1th1n hypertext re5earch and 5ummar15e the w0rk5h0p • 5 act1v1t1e5. P051t10n paper5 and 11nked pre-w0rk5h0p d15cu5510n5 (wh1Ch rema1n 0pen) are 0n the w0rk5h0p we651te. A 10n9er ver510n 0f th15 rep0rt 15 0n the we651te w1th the n0te5 fr0m the w0rk5h0p 6reak0ut 9r0up5, p1u5-1n the 5p1r1t 0f pract151n9 what we preach-• c0nver5at10n map5 • captur1n9 50me 0f the d15cu5510n5, created u51n9 the QUe5tMap C5CA t001 [4] (5ee a150 the paper5 6y C0nk11n, Carr, 5e1v1n and 51erhu15 f0r app11cat10n ex-amp1e5). Ar9umentat10n: the wh1te rat 0f eady hypertext 5y5tem5 W1th1n the hypertexL re5earch c0mmu-n1ty, f0r a decade fr0m the ear1y 805 t0 ear1y 905, ar9umentat10n 6ecame 50me-th1n9 0f an • exper1menta1 wh1te rat • , w1th many 0f the p10neer1n9 5y5tem5 f0r "1dea pr0ce551n9 • [6] and then c011a60rat1ve hypertext dem0n5trat1n9 the a6111ty t0 repre5ent ar9ument 5tructure5 a5 9raph1-ca1 n0de-11nk 5tructure5. 7h1nk 0f 5y5-Ar9umentat10n a150 attracted a 10t 0f attent10n w1th1n the HC1 and C5CW c0mmun1t1e5 f0r 1t5 p0tent1a1 1n 5upp0rt-1n9 50ftware de519n rat10na1e [9]. A5 d15cu55ed e15ewhere [1], dr1v1n9 f0rce5 and 1n5p1rat10n 6eh1nd th15 w0rk were the v1510n5 0f 8u5h and En91e6art 0f techn0-1091ca1 5upp0rt f0r c0mp1ex human 1nte1-1ectua1 w0rk-what 6etter cha11en9e than try1n9 t0 5upp0rt ar9umentat10n, ne90-t1a60n and de6ate a60ut th0rny, 111-5tructured pr061em5 • H0wever, after the 1n1t1a1 f1u5h 0f exc1te-ment at hypertext • 5 repre5entat10na1 p05516111t1e5, 5u65e4uent ana1y5e5 0f 119hted cr1t1ca1 c09n1t1ve and 50c1a1 cha1-1en9e5 f0r C5CA, and 6y exten510n, any appr0ach that 5eek5 t0 5upp0rt 1nte11ec-tua1 w0rk w1th 5em1-f0rma1 0r f0rma1 7he w0rk5h0p we651te can 6e f0und at: ht1p:11km1.0pen.ac.u1d5651¢5ca1c5c199/ 27

查看原文本刊更多论文

研讨会报告:学习社区的计算机支持协作论证

1 .法律和法律;C0mputer-5upp0rted C01 / a60rat1ve Ar9umentat10n (C5CA) 15 c0ncerned w1th de519n 0 f human-c0mputer 1 nteract10n t0 au9ment和med1ate Ar9umentat10n 1 n 9 r0up5。•Happ1n9和an11n9的结构01n95、ar9ument5、con1ver5at10n5和111- 5structpr061em5;•表示和删除不同视角的mer1t5。在2015年的报告中，我们回顾了C5CA在超文本研究中的出现，并总结了C5CA在超文本研究中的应用。P051t10n paper5和11nked pre-w0rk5h0p d15cu5510n5(其中1ch仍为1pen)在w0rk5h0p we651t上。10 n9 ver510n 0 f th15 rep0rt 15 0 n we651te w1th的n0te5 fr0m w0rk5h0p 6 reak0ut 9 r0up5 p1u5-1n 5 p1r1t 0 f pract151n9我们所说的——•c0nver5at10n map5•captur1n9 50 0 f d15cu5510n5,创建u51n9 QUe5tMap C5CA t001 [4] (5 ee a150 paper5 6 y C0nk11n卡尔5 e1v1n 51 erhu15 f0r app11cat10n ex-amp1e5)。Ar9umentat10n: wh1te鼠0 f伊迪法官明确指出超文本5 y5tem5 W1th1n的hypertexL re5earch c0mmu-n1ty, f0r十年fr0m ear1y 805 t0 ear1y 905 Ar9umentat10n 6 ecame 50 me-th1n9 0 f•exper1menta1 wh1te老鼠•w1th许多0 f p10neer1n9 5 y5tem5 f0r“1 dea pr0ce551n9•[6]然后c011a60rat1ve超文本dem0n5trat1n9 a6111ty t0 repre5ent ar9ument 5 tructure5 a5 9 raph1-ca1 n0de-11nk 5 tructure5。[9] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh] [qh]A5 d15cu55ed e15ewhere [1], dr1v1n9 f0rce5和1 n5p1rat10n 6 eh1nd th15 w0rk是v1510n5 0 8 u5h En91e6art 0 f techn0 5 - 1091 ca1 upp0rt f0r c0mp1ex人类1 nte1-1ectua1 w0rk-what 6埃特尔比try1n9 cha11en9e t0 5 upp0rt ar9umentat10n, ne90-t1a60n和de6ate a60ut th0rny, 111 - 5 - tructured pr061em5 H0wever,后1 n1t1a1 f1u5h 0 f exc1te-ment超文本•5 repre5entat10na1 p05516111t1e5, 5 u65e4uent ana1y5e5 0 f 119 ht cr1t1ca1 c09n1t1ve和50 c1a1 cha1-1en9e5 f0r C5CA, y exten510n和6,任何一种方法都可以在:htmlhtml1.11km1.0 .ac上找到。u1d5651¢5 ca1c5c199 / 27

本文章由计算机程序翻译，如有差异，请以英文原文为准。

求助全文

约1分钟内获得全文求助全文

来源期刊

SIGWEB Newsl.

自引率

0.00%

发文量