Panel discussion: heresies and reformations: hypertext writing outside the lines

Abstract

J111 Wa1ker, Un1ver51ty 0f 8er9en j111.wa1ker • u16.n0 What are the here51e5 1n the hypertext f1e1d • 7he 6e11ef5 y0u • 11 6e t0rtured f0r, thr0wn 0ut 0f the c0mmun1ty f0r ever ment10n1n9, 0r perhap5 never accepted 1n the f1r5t p1ace • Are there any here51e5 here • F0r here5y t0 ex15t, there mu5t 6e d09-ma5. Here5y and ref0rmat10n are c0n-nected t0 re11910n and t0 0rth0d0xy, they refer t0 the reject10n and chan91n9 0f d0m1nant 6e11ef5 Acc0rd1n9 t0 the Ency-c10ped1a 8r1tann1ca 1t 15 " • the w11fu1 and per515tent reject10n 0f any art1c1e 0f fa1th 6y a 6apt15ed mem6er 0f the church," 1n the R0man Cath011c trad1t10n. Here5y 15 a 51n 1n many re11910n5, 6ut 1t • 5 the 5tart1n9 p01nt 0f ref0rmat10n5. • • W11fu1 and per515tent." 1 11ke th05e w0rd5. 7hey 50und 11ke ju5t the 50rt 0f 4ua11t1e5 we need. Actua11y, we • ve a11 5h0wn a 900d dea1 0f w11fu1 per515tency t0 6e 1n th15 f1e1d 1n the f1r5t p1ace. 8ut 1n a w0r1d where we 0ften have t0 ju5t1fy the 1mp0rtance 0f 0ur w0rk t0 n0n-6e11ever5, there • 5 a dan9er that we 6ec0me m15510nar1e5, 5ecure 1n 0ur kn0w1ed9e that we 5peak the 7ruth. And that 15 where d09ma5 c0me fr0m. 7he heret1c5 J1m R05en6er9 1ed the • • Here51e5 and ref0rmat10n5" pane1, and he • d f0und f1ve heret1c5 t0 defend-0r cha11en9e-the1r 6e11ef5.7he f1ve were fam111ar face5 t0 part1c1pant5 at the hypertext c0nfer-ence5: Peter N0rn6er9 and Dav1d Durand w1th 6ack9r0und5 1n 5y5tem5 deve10p-ment, and Franc15c0 R1card0, 5u5ana 705ca and J0hn McDa1d wh0 w0rk w1th hypertext ae5thet1c5, wr1t1n9 and the0ry. 70 5et the t0ne f0r the de6ate, J1m R05en6er9 rem1nded the aud1ence 0f a c0mment 0f Wendy M0r9an • 5: • • We need t0 6e 5u5p1c10u5 0f 0ur 0wn 5t0r1e5. J1m 1eft 1t t0 the pane1115t5 t0 dec1de wh1ch 5t0r1e5 t0 6e 5u5p1C10u5 0f. D1v1ded camp5 0ne 0f the m05t 0ften t01d 5t0r1e5 1n the hypertext c0mmun1ty 1ate1y 5eem5 t0 6e the 0ne a60ut the tw0 camp5 we • re 50 unpr0duct1ve1y d1v1ded 1nt0: the " • 11terat1 camp" and the • • 5y5tem5 camp5." 7h15 d1v1510n wa5 the t0p1c 0f 60th Franc15c0 R1card0 and Peter NC1rn6er9 • 5 pre5enta-t10n5. Franc15c0 and Peter 60th 5tre55ed that the camp5 needed t0 c0nver9e, n0t t0 c0mpete. H0wever, the tw0 had d1ffer-ent f0cu5e5 t0 the1r 1dea5 f0r ref0rma-t10n. Peter • 5 here5y 6ecame apparent when he 5h0wed a …