Breaking Shortcuts by Masking for Robust Visual Reasoning

Abstract

Visual reasoning is a challenging but important task that is gaining momentum. Examples include reasoning about what will happen next in film, or interpreting what actions an image advertisement prompts. Both tasks are "puzzles" which invite the viewer to combine knowledge from prior experience, to find the answer. Intuitively, providing external knowledge to a model should be helpful, but it does not necessarily result in improved reasoning ability. An algorithm can learn to find answers to the prediction task yet not perform generalizable reasoning. In other words, models can leverage "shortcuts" between inputs and desired outputs, to bypass the need for reasoning. We develop a technique to effectively incorporate external knowledge, in a way that is both interpretable, and boosts the contribution of external knowledge for multiple complementary metrics. In particular, we mask evidence in the image and in retrieved external knowledge. We show this masking successfully focuses the method’s attention on patterns that generalize. To properly understand how our method utilizes external knowledge, we propose a novel side evaluation task. We find that with our masking technique, the model can learn to select useful knowledge pieces to rely on.1