A. Vergun, S. Yagelo, O. Vergun, I. Havryliuk, Z. Kit
{"title":"Academic integrity of applicants: curriculum and examination of scientific papers in the context of counteraction to academic plagiarism","authors":"A. Vergun, S. Yagelo, O. Vergun, I. Havryliuk, Z. Kit","doi":"10.38014/osvita.2021.88.03","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"As you know, the principles of academic culture and integrity in the current state of university education in Ukraine are often simply perceived as an abstract, but necessary for the European integration of education postulate. Codes of ethics and regulations on combating academic plagiarism are created on the basis of recommendations of the Ministry of Education and Science, regulate the activities of employees and students in the context of prevention and detection of falsifications, violations of academic integrity, including academic plagiarism. The establishment of the principles of academic culture and integrity in educational institutions is a necessary prerequisite for building a strong civic culture in society. Expert evaluation of scientific papers, including anti-plagiarism, in our opinion is an important prerequisite for the adequacy of complex scientific topics and objectifies the overall assessment of the quality of presentation of research results, including dissertations,monographs, manuals, articles and abstracts. The aim of the work was to improve measures to combat academic dishonesty and plagiarismbased on the analysis of current legislation, orders and regulations of Danylo Halytskyi Lviv National Medical University, creation and implementation of a new discipline for PhD students to acquire the necessary knowledge, skills and abilities. based on the topics of meaningful modules, created taking into account the experience of examination of scientific and educational works. In total for the three-year period (2018-2020) 5992 inspections were carried out and violations of academic integrity were confirmed in 611 works, which was the reason for their rejection. Algorithmic logical functional sequence of anti-plagiarism examination of dissertations and abstracts with analysis of the percentage of uniqueness of the text by the method of shingles with optimized settings was used to conduct the initial examination of dissertations to detect academic plagiarism. Deep search parameters and deep verification by Unichek, Plagiarism Detector Pro v. 1092”, etc. with further maternity check and establishment of the percentage of uniqueness of the text by the freely accessible program “AdvegoPlagiatus”. Based on the analysisof the causes, trends and spread of academic plagiarism in the university community for applicants and graduate students was created and implemented the discipline “Information support, academic integrity and research ethics” which is aimed at gaining analytical competencies, flexible skills “soft skills”. necessary during the planning and implementation of dissertation research and ensuring adequate communication in the scientific community. It consists of three content modules “Academic Integrity and Anti-Plagiarism”, “Scientific Ethics”, “Information Technology and Patent and Literary Support of Research Papers”. Lectures, seminars and topics of independent work are aimed at acquiring analytical competencies, flexible skills “soft skills” needed during the planning and implementation of dissertation research and ensuring adequate communication in the scientific community, the formation of graduate students’ theoretical knowledge and practical skills and skills in compliance with ethical and moral and legal principles in the planning and implementation of scientific research with human participation and with the use of laboratory animals, obtaining by graduate students and applicants knowledge of research activities and acquisition of skills of independent research, features of patent research and preparation of reporting documentation. Postgraduate students acquire knowledge of current legislation on academic integrity and anti-plagiarism; ethical aspects of scientist behavior and communication; research planning, organization and tactics strategies; liability for breach of academic integrity; basics of statistical conclusion, counteraction to conflicts of interest, elimination of risk factors and errors in ensuring academic integrity, which determines the social and professional mobility of research and teaching staff, promotes diversification of higher education, increasing the value of scientific knowledge and professional experience. Prospects for further research are to improve algorithms for detecting academic plagiarism and scientific falsifications, optimizing measures to prevent anddetect manifestations of academic dishonesty.","PeriodicalId":114992,"journal":{"name":"Higher Education of Ukraine in the Context of Integration to European Educational Space","volume":"1 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2021-11-30","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Higher Education of Ukraine in the Context of Integration to European Educational Space","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.38014/osvita.2021.88.03","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
As you know, the principles of academic culture and integrity in the current state of university education in Ukraine are often simply perceived as an abstract, but necessary for the European integration of education postulate. Codes of ethics and regulations on combating academic plagiarism are created on the basis of recommendations of the Ministry of Education and Science, regulate the activities of employees and students in the context of prevention and detection of falsifications, violations of academic integrity, including academic plagiarism. The establishment of the principles of academic culture and integrity in educational institutions is a necessary prerequisite for building a strong civic culture in society. Expert evaluation of scientific papers, including anti-plagiarism, in our opinion is an important prerequisite for the adequacy of complex scientific topics and objectifies the overall assessment of the quality of presentation of research results, including dissertations,monographs, manuals, articles and abstracts. The aim of the work was to improve measures to combat academic dishonesty and plagiarismbased on the analysis of current legislation, orders and regulations of Danylo Halytskyi Lviv National Medical University, creation and implementation of a new discipline for PhD students to acquire the necessary knowledge, skills and abilities. based on the topics of meaningful modules, created taking into account the experience of examination of scientific and educational works. In total for the three-year period (2018-2020) 5992 inspections were carried out and violations of academic integrity were confirmed in 611 works, which was the reason for their rejection. Algorithmic logical functional sequence of anti-plagiarism examination of dissertations and abstracts with analysis of the percentage of uniqueness of the text by the method of shingles with optimized settings was used to conduct the initial examination of dissertations to detect academic plagiarism. Deep search parameters and deep verification by Unichek, Plagiarism Detector Pro v. 1092”, etc. with further maternity check and establishment of the percentage of uniqueness of the text by the freely accessible program “AdvegoPlagiatus”. Based on the analysisof the causes, trends and spread of academic plagiarism in the university community for applicants and graduate students was created and implemented the discipline “Information support, academic integrity and research ethics” which is aimed at gaining analytical competencies, flexible skills “soft skills”. necessary during the planning and implementation of dissertation research and ensuring adequate communication in the scientific community. It consists of three content modules “Academic Integrity and Anti-Plagiarism”, “Scientific Ethics”, “Information Technology and Patent and Literary Support of Research Papers”. Lectures, seminars and topics of independent work are aimed at acquiring analytical competencies, flexible skills “soft skills” needed during the planning and implementation of dissertation research and ensuring adequate communication in the scientific community, the formation of graduate students’ theoretical knowledge and practical skills and skills in compliance with ethical and moral and legal principles in the planning and implementation of scientific research with human participation and with the use of laboratory animals, obtaining by graduate students and applicants knowledge of research activities and acquisition of skills of independent research, features of patent research and preparation of reporting documentation. Postgraduate students acquire knowledge of current legislation on academic integrity and anti-plagiarism; ethical aspects of scientist behavior and communication; research planning, organization and tactics strategies; liability for breach of academic integrity; basics of statistical conclusion, counteraction to conflicts of interest, elimination of risk factors and errors in ensuring academic integrity, which determines the social and professional mobility of research and teaching staff, promotes diversification of higher education, increasing the value of scientific knowledge and professional experience. Prospects for further research are to improve algorithms for detecting academic plagiarism and scientific falsifications, optimizing measures to prevent anddetect manifestations of academic dishonesty.
如您所知,乌克兰大学教育现状中的学术文化和诚信原则往往被简单地视为抽象的,但对于欧洲一体化教育假设是必要的。根据教育和科学部的建议,制定了打击学术剽窃的道德准则和规章,规范了雇员和学生在防止和发现伪造、违反学术诚信、包括学术剽窃方面的活动。在教育机构中确立学术文化和诚信原则是建设强大的社会公民文化的必要前提。我们认为,对科学论文的专家评估,包括反剽窃,是复杂科学主题充分性的重要先决条件,也是对研究成果(包括论文、专著、手册、文章和摘要)展示质量的全面客观评估。这项工作的目的是在分析利沃夫国立医科大学现行立法、命令和条例的基础上,改进打击学术不诚实和剽窃的措施,为博士生建立和实施一门新的学科,以获得必要的知识、技能和能力。本课题以有意义的模块为基础,考虑到科教作品的考试经验而创设。在2018-2020年的三年中,共进行了5992次检查,其中611篇作品被确认存在违反学术诚信的行为,这是被拒绝的原因。采用优化设置瓦片法分析文本唯一性百分比的论文和摘要反抄袭检查算法逻辑功能序列,对论文进行初步检查,检测学术抄袭。通过Unichek, Plagiarism Detector Pro v. 1092等进行深度搜索参数和深度验证,并通过免费访问的程序“AdvegoPlagiatus”进行进一步的母体检查和建立文本的唯一性百分比。在分析大学学术剽窃的原因、趋势和蔓延的基础上,为申请人和研究生创建并实施了“信息支持、学术诚信和研究伦理”学科,旨在获得分析能力、灵活技能和“软技能”。在规划和实施论文研究期间是必要的,并确保科学界的充分沟通。包括“学术诚信与反抄袭”、“科学伦理”、“信息技术与专利与科研论文文献支持”三个内容模块。讲座,研讨会和独立工作的主题旨在获得在规划和实施论文研究期间所需的分析能力,灵活技能“软技能”,并确保科学界的充分沟通。培养研究生在规划和实施人类参与和使用实验动物的科学研究中符合伦理、道德和法律原则的理论知识和实践技能和技能,使研究生和申请人获得研究活动的知识和获得自主研究的技能、专利研究的特点和编写报告文件。研究生学习有关学术诚信和反剽窃的现行立法知识;科学家行为和交流的伦理问题;研究计划、组织和战术战略;违反学术诚信的责任;统计结论的基础,利益冲突的对抗,消除风险因素和错误,确保学术诚信,这决定了研究和教学人员的社会和专业流动性,促进了高等教育的多样化,增加了科学知识和专业经验的价值。进一步研究的前景是改进检测学术剽窃和科学伪造的算法,优化预防和检测学术不诚实表现的措施。