J. SAINSBURY PLC v FROMAGERIES BEL SA

Abstract

H1 Trade marks – Invalidation proceedings – Shape mark with dimension and colour limitations – Assessment of essential characteristics - Colours – Graphical representation - Requirement of clarity and precision - Whether limitation to “the colour red” sufficient – Whether graphical representation and written description inconsistent - Appeal to High Court – Admission of additional evidence on appeal – Relevance of other registrations with similar limitations